was a crap-tastic WR on some terrible Indianapolis Colts teams. He’s not much better as a football writer, either.

if i remember correctly…

for some dusty cow town in the mountains. The others don’t.

This is why, as Guru has implied, we need to be yelling and screaming their names in our votes and any other way we can.

I like him, but Eddie has been producing from day one. Bump Slaton off the list and put Royal at #5 and that should pretty much solve everything… world hunger, peace in our time, AIDS….

Then again this is why i dont subscribe to SI or read it online. What could be a better way to shove it to all these writers than Denver winning the Super Bowl

I hereby summarily declare Eddie Royal Offensive Rookie of the Year.

Learn it. Live it. Know it.

slaton over royal? no. qb is going to get it’s props(ryan will win), because of the importance and difficulty of the position, and the increase in wins. rb is all numbers, and easy to compare players. but if you look at what royal has done at the wr and returner positions since game one, he definitely should be given consideration. anyone have his stats handy(where’s the new stat guy?) total yards should be pretty impressive, as well as receptions. unfortunately, ol for rookie-of-the-year often get overlooked for the #’s guys. if there was a rookie-lineman-of-the-year, this would be no contest