Eli, Big Ben, and Romo all have the exact same winning %. Romo has better % completion, Cutler yards by 20, Cutler has 2 more touchdowns, 1 less int and a QB rating better by 4 pts. I dont think those are stats to say Cutler is the BEST of that bunch, and actually Big Ben has better stats than Mr. Cutler. oh yeah, TWO games.

I think Romo is pretty damn good. I would probably put Big Ben, Romo, Cutler, Brees and maybe Rivers. I’m not that impressed with Eli and although it burnes me to put in Rivers he has good accuracy and vision but I wouldn’t want him in my lockerroom. Cutler had an ok year last year despite his illness and is having a great couple of games thus far… but it is only a couple of games. I expect him to continue to perform like this though and by the end of the year I bet he will be ranked #1 no matter who’s team glasses you look through.

Eli, Big Ben, and Romo all have the exact same winning %. Romo has better % completion, Cutler yards by 20, Cutler has 2 more touchdowns, 1 less int and a QB rating better by 4 pts. I dont think those are stats to say Cutler is the BEST of that bunch, and actually Big Ben has better stats than Mr. Cutler. oh yeah, TWO games.

I really like Romo and Ben, but don’t forget that Cutler is the baby of the group, and is competing right along with the others who have a lot more experience. That said, if I couldn’t have Cutler on my team, I think I’d take Romo.

Did you really go back to your pathetic Cowgirls site and write a fanpost to point out how “unbelievably ignorant” Broncos fans are?

If you don’t want our opinion…DON’T ASK

I think you’re a disgusting and despicable individual!!!!

http://www.bloggingtheboys.com/2008/9/19/617868/best-young-qb

I think it’s from the ESPN show with Woody Paige and the other sports columnist and whenever they say something the host likes then he adds points.

Let me ask you thad, what are you looking for in a QB? Are we building or rebuilding a team? Are we looking to add a solid proven QB? or are we looking for the most upside? Below are my assessments of all the QB’s mentioned. I didn’t put them in any order because I’m not sure what you are looking for.

1. Rivers- His mouth would never survive in my locker room, he’s not a winner IMO.
2. Manning- Not even in the running IMO, to inconsistent and rode a great Defense to a SB.
3. Romo-Excellent QB with good leadership skills, has yet to win in the plaoyoffs but I think that will come. Probably the 2nd best on this list if you are looking for proven talent. Still has a little upside.
4. Big Ben- THe most proven winner of the bunch, this would be my pick if I was looking for proven talent that can win now. Probably as good as he is going to get which is damm good but he is in his prime right now.
5. Cutler-Has by far the most upside, physical tools are extremely good, has begun to show the intangibles of a winner and great leader, time will tell if this pans out but Cutler has the most upside here.

You can tell from my opinions who I would pick depending on what I am looking for as far as upside vs. proven ability. It all depends on what a fella is looking for. BTW, I don’t mind you coming and asking questions like this, I think it is fun, but to go back to your sight and blast us is pretty classless IMO. Have you watched every game Cutler has played this year including preseason? How about training camp other than when the boys were here? We are pretty high on Cutler and with very good reason. I have tried to be objective in my post so do I deserve the blasting you gave us on your sight? We obviously know more about our boy than you do just like you know more about Romo. I think it’s cool that you are high on your QB, thats as it should be, however you shouldn’t blast us for being high on ours. Anyway, above is my answer to your original question.

OK, I can’t reply on the Cowboy Blogsite, as there is a one day “cool-down” period before you can start posting. (which I respect) But this is pretty funny:

So i went out to the other four blogs (Steelers, Broncos, Giants, and Chargers) that Scouts Inc included in their young QB discussion and posed the question to all of them. The majority of the bloggs of course put their guy first, which I guess as a fan makes sense. My thoughts were Big Ben, Romo, Cutler, Eli and Rivers. But i would like you to check out the UNBELIEVALBE ignorance of the bronco’s blog. It was pretty rediculous of their thoughts. I wasnt trying to go over anywhere and talk crap about their QB, for even being a ROMO fan, i but Big Ben first. But the talk that Romo has had the worst of the 5 as in the starts to this year just made me completely laugh!! Check it out.

Bronco’s Blogg Here

Now, in spite of the fact that only 6 or 7 people had replied to his post, he has taken our measure as a community, and we are apparently unbelievably ignorant. (but hey, most of us can spell, and pen a fair bit of prose) No one attacked Romo, other than to say that he was developing a rep as a choker. Several compliments were directed towards Romo, and several comments spoke to the fact that we would naturally tend to be biased towards our own QB.
Now, apparently calling Romo “over-rated” was the final straw. (on a very anemic camel) Fair enough = ) But the Cowboys and their stars are always over-rated… its the nature of the media (whom we entrust to deliver our opinions to us) to make safe judgments, and then go over board with the enthusiasm, leading to disgust from fans of other stars. (Fantasy Football tends to highlight and amplify both the hype and the following disgust, in my opinion.) Technically, saying someone is over-rated doesn’t necessarily mean that you also think they suck… but I understand the inference. Romo definitely does NOT suck… but in light of his short track record, especially in the play-offs, I might take either of the 2 Superbowl winners, or Cutler, who impresses most with his poise and maturity, over Romo. That doesn’t mean Romo is a loser (other than in several play-off games = ) but it might indeed mean that in spite of his stats, I prefer a different QB, meaning that I consider Romo to be over-rated.
That is an opinion, which Thad asked for. It may incorrect, but it is not ignorant. I also believe Romo has a couple Superbowls in him… which I hope also involve Cutler, whom I believe would win. So… I would choose Cutler in the poll above, again showing my ignorance and doubly offending Thad, for which I apologize.

Of all these QBs Romo has had the greatest amount of talent surrounding him. Of any of the five QBs you’d have to argue that he has the best Offesive line, WRs, TE (arguably), and has had great RBs. Not to mention a stellar defense. and he STILL CAN"T WIN IT!!!! That is why Romo is on the bottom of the list along with Rivers.

+4

I went over to the ole Tex Land area where thad728 posted. The only reply was from someone called DC_fan. I guess there isn’t much interest in what thad was saying.