Having a program
It's well known (on this site at least) that the Broncos have both the most wins, and the highest degree of consistency in the last 30 years. Following them, in terms of average wins, are Pittsburgh, Miami, San Francisco, and Dallas. These teams all have a program, and it's the biggest reason for the sustained success.
I've always believed in the concept of a program, and I was reading Mike Lombardi the other day when he criticized Washington's lack of one. I liken the idea to a college football program, where a coach gets hired, and it's expected that he'll be there for a long time. He recruits and hires assistants, based upon specific overarching philosophies. If you think of a school like Penn State, they've been doing the same things for decades under Joe Paterno. When a kid commits to play there, he knows who the coaches will be, he knows how the schemes will look, and he knows Penn State will be competitive annually, and consistently bring in more good talent. The relentless consistency of the program is what breeds the consistency of the win-loss record.
To consider the idea of a program in the NFL, look at the five teams I previously mentioned as the most successful of the past 30 years. There are many similarities between them.
The Broncos have had two distinct programs in the last 30 years. There was the Dan Reeves program of conservative ball-control offense/blitzing 3-4 defense from 1981 through 1994 (I include the 2 Wade Phillips years as a continuation of the Reeves program.) From 1995 through the present, we've seen the Mike Shanahan program featuring a run-heavy West Coast offense/4-3 1-gap defense.
For Pittsburgh, there has been only one program, as Bill Cowher continued in the same way as Chuck Noll. Mike Tomlin is from a different school, so it remains to be seen what happens there in the near-term future.
Miami had the Don Shula program, followed by a Jimmy Johnson/Dave Wannstedt regime for 8 years, and then some wilderness that has seen them go from Nick Saban to Cam Cameron. By hiring Bill Parcells and Tony Sparano, the Dolphins committed to building a new program (Bill would be a great program builder if he stayed anywhere for very long. He's more of a great program-starter.)
The 49ers had a long-lived program that encompassed the tenures of Bill Walsh, George Seifert, and Steve Mariucci. It was really the Eddie DeBartolo program, and when his sister and her husband (who are not good owners) took over the team on a permanent basis in 2002, they tried to put their own stamp on the team, promptly leading them into the wilderness personified by Dennis Erickson and Mike Nolan.
Finally, the Cowboys transitioned from a Tex Schramm/Tom Landry program to what started as a Jimmy Johnson program, but is most certainly now a Jerry Jones program. He's had a fairly long list of coaches (Johnson, Switzer, Gailey, Campo, Parcells, Wade Phillips,) but it's Jerry's team, and he serves as the General Manager.
Now, in the NFL, less teams than you might expect actually have a program. For purposes of determining who does, let's say that the best indicator would be either a coach or a GM who is entrenched to the point that it is close to inconceivable that their team owner would want to fire them. Using that as our filter, here is the list.
Coach-Dominated
Denver, Philadelphia, New England, Tennesee, Tampa Bay, Seattle (although they become more GM-dominated when Jim Mora takes over next season,)
GM-Dominated
Indianapolis (Dungy was hired by Polian, and will leave before him too,) San Diego, Baltimore, Kansas City, Green Bay.
Owner-Dominated
Pittsburgh, Dallas
That's 13 of 32 teams with definite, long-term programs. A couple of years ago, you'd say Carolina's John Fox and Marty Hurney were safe, but they have to get some wins this season. Jack Del Rio is pretty secure in Jacksonville, but it's not quite inconceivable that they could decide to fire him. Newer regimes in Houston and New Orleans look promising, and I was tempted to include them, but the credibility isn't all the way established there. Tom Coughlin almost did get fired last year, and then won the Super Bowl. I crossed out Detroit, because the Ford family never considers firing Matt Millen, who has hired three different Head Coaches, but they really ought to.
Our program changed its player acquisition methodology somewhat this season. Instead of diving head-first into free agency and trades, the Broncos focused more heavily on the draft than in some past years. The characteristics of the players they targeted are the same, though. The program lives, and we all know what to expect from our team. I think we'll all be happy when the Broncos improve this season, and really assert themselves as a contender to win a Super Bowl next season. Thanks to Pat Bowlen's unwavering trust in Mike Shanahan's program, we have the luxury of knowing that our team will always be in the mix, and that's a great feeling to have as fans.
This is a Fan-Created Comment on MileHighReport.com. The opinion here is not necessarily shared by the editorial staff of MHR
9 recs |
9 comments
Comments
Great Post!
How does this relate to the up and down structure that many attribute to the league these days (see comments from raider fans who keep warning that the league is full of ups and downs, and that we are primed for a down time)?
As I understand your post, the Broncos have been following a program to insure that they rarely have years like the raiders have been suffering through, and to insure that they are always in the hunt for a trophy. Does that mean that the raiders are doomed to fail because they have abandoned the program model for a buy a title model?
"It's the first time that I've probably ever seen a 260 pound back run into a free safety and go flat on his back, I mean it was exciting." ~John Elway
by jibbons on Sep 6, 2008 5:29 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs
You try to buy one when you can't build one...
None of these program teams I listed ever really rebuild, because they’re constantly building. As I scan the list again, I only see the Chiefs who have undertaken any kind of rebuilding effort lately. The Raiders have the Al Davis program, which has been a failure for most of the last 10 years. It’s like the Matt Millen program in Detroit, meaning there is a consistency of ineptitude. Al can’t fire himself as owner, other than selling the team, and that team won’t be sold until he dies.
The Raiders are not in a cyclical situation. Anybody who says they are is delusional. They are at the bottom because they operate like a team that should be at the bottom. They pick high in the Draft every year, and all they can hope for is that they get lucky with people like Russell and McFadden, and that those guys produce better results than the quality of Al Davis’s management of the team deserves. The best thing for the Raiders would be for Al to just retire, and let Lane Kiffin run the team. He’s the best coach they’ve had since Mike Shanahan, and the only reason they have to be optimistic at this point.
"I wouldn't ever set out to hurt anyone deliberately unless it was, you know, important --like a league game or something." DICK BUTKUS
by Ted Bartlett on Sep 6, 2008 5:58 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
The raiders have a program, sort of
It’s called the ‘Al Davis’ Whatever the Heck I Want’ program.
Seriously, that may explain a great deal. Perhaps I’m just not aware of it (and if so, I’d love to learn more), but as far as I’ve seen there is no established program in terms of their longer term over-reaching philosophy of ball control, run versus pass (currently a ‘run instead of pass’, but they are trying to change that), theory of defense and so forth.
The Broncs got toasted last year when they tried to change the philosophy of the defensive aspect of their program. If it had worked, Shanahan would have (again) been hailed as a genius, but since it failed it has led to a change in how the Broncos do business. The Goodman’s have established themselves and the past draft year has shown the wisdom of that philosophy. The offensive aspect of the program is evolving further with Bates/Cutler.
However, the program is still the same – a West Coast derived, ZB oriented approach. The overall program philosophy includes a heavy emphasis on off-season training commitments that yielded an amazingly high level of attendance. This allowed the teammates to begin to bond, a process that continued through OTAs and into training camp. Whatever the final win/loss record this season, they have the basis for a great team right now, and that is greatly due to the Broncos understanding of the idea of a ‘program.’
Atwater for the Hall!
by Emmett Smith on Sep 6, 2008 6:04 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs
Its funny, had Davis realized he was getting old, out of touch, becoming obsessive...
growing more out of touch, more obsessive—he might still have one of the great programs in the NFL. Somehow he went from, “Just Win Baby,” to “Just do what I say…Period!!” I can’t see Bowlen ever doing that to this team.
Broncos broncos everywhere and all the league did blink,
Broncos broncos everywhere think moldy faiders stink!
by Mike Clark on Sep 6, 2008 6:05 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs
Re: Al Davis
As an old guy, I can empathise with Al Davis. He’s put his life into not only the Raiders, but also the AFL. Davis was the head of the Raiders in the early 60’s, when they (Patriots, "Jets (they were the Dallas Titans or something then, but same franchise)’, Oilers, Bills, Broncos, Raiders, Chargers and Chiefs) challenged the mighty NFL. After a year or two, Davis agreed to leave the Raiders and be the AFL Commissioner. He was a prime mover in establishing the fledgling league, to the point that the NFL agreed to a merger. Whereupon, Davis went back to the Raiders. I will tip my hat to Al Davis for his accomplishment. I can empathise with him not wanting to give up control of the team he loves, even though I think he is not doing it any good any more.
while yet unspoken, you are master of the word. After it is spoken, the word is master of you.
by bradley on Sep 6, 2008 6:23 PM MDT up reply actions 1 recs
I will tip my hat as well..
I tried to do it with my comment—but didn’t get it done—you did.
Broncos broncos everywhere and all the league did blink,
Broncos broncos everywhere think moldy faiders stink!
by Mike Clark on Sep 6, 2008 8:17 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
Why did I type that--I don't like Davis--period!!
Broncos broncos everywhere and all the league did blink,
Broncos broncos everywhere think moldy faiders stink!
by Mike Clark on Sep 8, 2008 7:31 PM MDT up reply actions 0 recs
I like the train of thought here
it brings around the point even harder so that doubters outside of Denver cannot ignore! Actually I was watching something similar the other day on ESPN U and they were talking about how USC is back on top after twenty years because they have kept the same program for the last 8 or so (under Carroll). They mentioned how few NCAA teams have this now and how few NFL teams do this. The only ones they mentioned were Denver Dallas and Pittsburgh. There is some MSM coverage for our poor boys!
" He goes against Champ everyday." -Jay Cutler
Davis to the Hall!
by Jon Tollerud on Sep 7, 2008 10:03 AM MDT reply actions 0 recs
Al Davis' Program
Just throw it deep, baby!
"It's all over Fat Man" - Tom Jackson to John Madden 1977 AFC Championship Game
"I love your analysis of our team. Its kinda like watching a spider monkey trying to figure out a jar of peanuts.. you know whats going on.. you know whats in there, but to actually figure it out, is just a bit beyond your mental skills..."
- Bronco Dano
by DesertBroncoFan on Sep 8, 2008 3:58 PM MDT reply actions 0 recs

by 



























