MHR University is meant to be a place to learn about the game of football. A lot of fans who love the game can find their appreciation deepens when they know the minute tactics or overarching strategies behind a team's approach to the game. Unfortunately, much of the football-reporting press avoids this teaching role. They throw out terms or concepts that may make sense to the few fans who have played or coached football, and they completely ignore other areas. Worse, they often put forth information that is misleading. The situation becomes worse when we factor in that football terms can mean different things in different regions and levels of play (for example, HS versus college), and you can see why many fans just watch the QB and hope for a score or turnover.
As I've written in MHR-U in the past, my favorite aspect of the game in terms of analysis is systems. With the strong caveat that no system is better than another (because the determining factor in a confrontation is who plays their system better), I think system analysis is perhaps the most under- and mis-reported aspect of the game. For example, few fans outside of MHR realize that the Cover-2 systems are not formations, nor do they require 2 safeties in deep coverage.
Many fans learn tactics, or they knew tactics from playing football when they were younger - proper stance, gap assignments, formation names, plays, and so forth. But the macro-level analysis (strategy) has always been on the shoulders of coaches. Perhaps this is why the discussion of systems (or styles, if you prefer), gets left behind.
For me, there is a jump in game appreciation when one moves from tactics to strategy. Tactics are the science of football. Break down game film, and you can scrutinize how well a team tackles, or passes, or covers, etc. But strategy (at least in football) is an art. Watch the game as a clash between two styles, and it is less a thing to pick apart and more to behold. For this reason, I would offer that there are three stages to watching football as a fan...
Stage One- You watch the game, knowing that you want your team to move the ball, and to stop the other guys. This is the level which most fans are at. The game of football is very popular, despite the fact that many fans don't know much beyond the basic rules of the game, and this is ok. These fans may not appreciate football on a deep level, but they love the sport, their teams, and their players. More power to them, because they are the ones who keep the sport moving.
Stage Two- You watch the game and know most of the terms and techniques. You likely played football when you were younger, and/or did some coaching. Otherwise, perhaps you learned a little bit from places like MHR, or from friends, or even from playing around on a game like Madden. (I'm not big on Madden as a sole source, but it has helped many people learn quite a bit about some aspects of the game). You are an educated fan. You might be a fantasy football player, you probably know the history of your team, and you might even watch a few replays here and there to break down what you have seen. You are likely a hardcore fan of your team.
When your team does something right, you tell your buddy that you saw it coming a mile away. In the background, you hear music like this. You see the games from the inside.
Stage three - You don't see any plays being run; instead, you see them unfold. You no longer see the game as just a clash of mere mortals on a field, but you see a divine guidance that comes from a higher power (the coach). Where others see techniques, you see artistry.
When your team does something right, the gates of Heaven are opened wide. You have an epiphany, and tears stream down your face. The touchdown isn't the focus of your joy, but the journey towards it. The touchdown isn't the end of a drive, but a transition to immortality (the scoreboard). You hear music like this. You no longer just see the game; you feel it.
With that out of the way, let's look at what we have so far on both sides of the ball.
Early Observations on Defense -
Major, major congratulations to member SlowWhiteGuy, who predicted a 5-2 look all the way back in May. I didn't see it coming, and he nailed it right on the head. While our (so called) OLBs have some of the skill sets to play at OLB, they have been used in the first two games more as 5-2 defensive ends. This makes the DEs on our rosters more like "defensive guards" (DGs). I say "so called" because these guys aren't even LBs, they are DEs whom we are told are being moves to OLB. They aren't!!! In fact, I'll go out on a limb.
Denver is not playing a true 3-4 at all. They are playing a true 5-2. Here's why...
- The base alignment is a 5-2 because there are 5 guys on the line.
- In terms of personnel, the outermost players on the line are DEs said to be converting to OLBs, not "3-4 LBs" playing up to the line.
That's right folks. While the formations will shift from time to time, the media types would be wrong to label this defense as a 3-4 . At least in the first two preseason games, we have been a 5-2 team. I didn't want to put this out there after our first game, but it seems more sure now. If this keeps up, when the season starts we may have to refer to players like Elvis Dumervil as DE again, and refer to players like Ryan McBean as DG (Ronald Fields is still NT). This leaves up with two "LBs" or "ILBs". Either is correct.
I still don't have enough to go on regarding the system type we are playing. I've been focused on tactics so far (looking for quality play from players), and feel the team is better. But I'll be watching the game on more of a macro level at this point. I'll be watching more closely to see what kind of assignments each player is getting.
Early Observations on Offense -
Still much too early to guess which system we are running. We are passing a lot, but that may be because we need to practice the passing game more than running right now. Because we have a new QB, new coach, and a new system, we probably need to be running more pass plays for practice during preseason. A few quick observations...
- A lot of screen passes; many are bubble screens (with other receivers are already on the side of the ball recipient to run block for him). This is very much what the Patriots do.
- Using a lot of RB in slot or wide. The threat is that they are better run blockers (see Hillis, FB) than receivers, but if they have good enough hands (see Peyton Hillis and others), then you can't leave them uncovered.
There are a lot of other things developing on the offense, but the use of RBs at WR or slot, and the sheer number of screens are easy to spot, and they don't strike me as pre-season "experiments".
Some Mail -
The brain trust of MHR got this question in email, and I took the stab at it...
Have you guys noticed that Champ Bailey is getting beat? Is this because he is learning a new system or is it something else?