Broncos Should've Hired Spagnuolo
Back when Mike Shanahan was fired, I immediately knew who I wanted to replace him. I wanted the Broncos to hire Steve Spagnuolo, who was then the defensive coordinator for the New York Giants. I felt like Pat Bowlen would tend toward the candidate who most reminded him of a young Shanny, and that was Josh McDainels. I really hoped that wouldn't happen, and I had a couple of solid reasons.
1. The Broncos were immensely talented on offense but lacked direction and talent as a defense. After 14 years with an offensive mastermind at the helm, I felt it was time to go in a different direction. Spagnuolo has taken the Rams, whose defense was in complete disarray and built a decent unit in two years. He knows how to identify defensive talents and maximize them. He also comes from the Jim Johnson school of blitzing which was becoming more prominent and successful throughout the league.
2. One year earlier, Spagnuolo kicked the crap out of Josh McDaniels in Super Bowl XLII. McDainels was offensive coordinator of the highest scoring team in history, but on the biggest stage, Spagnuolo had him figured out. A lot of people will credit the late offensive heroics by Eli Manning and company, but for me, the Giants win came down to the fact that Spagnuolo outcoached Josh McDaniels. He was the only defensive coordinator that confused Tom Brady at all during the 2007 season.
3. Every other coordinator who has come out of New England has failed miserably. Charlie Weis, Romeo Crennel, and up until today, I thought the worst of the bunch was the absolutely clueless wonder, Eric Mangini. Now, I'm starting to think that McDaniels might be the dunce. The fact is, in New England, Bill Belichick is the defensive coordinator and Tomo Brady is the offensive coordinator. Everyone else deserves a participation trophy at best.
The Rams have improved about as much as the Broncos have regressed in the last 1.5 seasons and that is a large amount on both counts. Watching the game today, I couldn't help but wonder what could have been. I also wonder what defensive coordinators like Leslie Frazier, Ron Rivera, or dare I say, Mike Nolan, might have planned for next season...
This is a Fan-Created Comment on MileHighReport.com. The opinion here is not necessarily shared by the editorial staff of MHR
11 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I thought
that Spag was going to be the guy. That is what people were saying in Jan. 09. However, Bowlen saw Shanahan in McDaniels, and decided to hire him, even if he may not have been ready. I will give McDaniels a chance, because stability should be desired, but if he is fired after this season, those fans that wanted Spag knew what they were talking about.
For the record, I thought that Shanny should have been given another year, anyway. I was stunned when I was coming out of the bathroom at my cousin’s house, and he told me that Shanahan was fired.
Wait wait wait...
the Giants win came down to the fact that Spagnuolo outcoached Josh McDaniels
The same Spags who got out coached by McDaniels just a few weeks prior? The same Spags whose defense gave up 38 points to those same Patriots?
You’re telling me that Eli Manning’s great escape and subsequent Tyree helmet catch, and Assante Samuel’s inability to catch a ball thrown right at him is on McDaniels?
Games like this make me laugh at the ridiculousness of the fans.
Owning the Patriots since September 9, 1960
I wouldn't sat Spag won against McDaniels but...
he learned from his mistakes in the first meeting and HELP the Giants win the Supwe Bowl. There is not a single person that is going to win or lose a game of football. It’s a team effort that wins or loses and yesterday Oakland was more hungry and ready to win. The biggest problem with D the Broncos yesterday was the fact that after the first 6 minutes of the game Denver gave up…QUIT on us, on them selfs, and on Pat Bowlen. There was only 2 players that stood out as giving any knid of effort and those players where Knowshon Moreno and Marcus Thomas. Everybody else, essecially Orton and McDaniels QUIT on us. There are the leaders but didn’t show up for the game and didn’t make any effort to make corrections for there mistakes or modivate there teamates, nobody help modivate there teamates, not even Dawkins! Denver needs leaders and nobody stepped up this week.
Looking at next week will tell if Denver has any kind of leaders on the team. If we come out and take care of business against SF, anyother team that hasn’t performed well this year, then and only then will we know the true direction of this team.
But the Pats adjusted too, their offense went down a scored a go ahead TD, and then their defense let them down. All NE had to do was sack Eli when they had him in their grasp, OR somehow unglue David Tyree’s hands from the ball on the throw, OR make an easy INT by Samuel (I mean the ball went right through his hands!) Any 1 of 3 of those Superbowl winning plays were blown by the Pats defense.
And yep, you are absolutely right in that football is such a team game, I said in another thread that Moreno was busting his butt in the 2nd half (and Thomas too, someone else had already mentioned him), I’m glad I got a #27 jersey this last year.
Owning the Patriots since September 9, 1960
You’re missing the point though. Yes, it was a close game and the Patriots very nearly won it. I will agree with anyone who says the Patriots outplayed the Giants aside from a few plays.
But what you’re forgetting is that Spagnuolo’s defense kept the Giants in the game in a year when ABSOLUTELY NOBODY could stop the Patriots before this game. He was the only coordinator who could slow them down enough to make a close game out of it and then they got some breaks and won.
That’s the point. You can’t get lucky and win if you let Tom Brady throw 4 TDs in the first half.
www.rhunekincaid.com
by YouAreSignedIn on Oct 26, 2010 5:26 PM MDT up reply actions
YES. The guy who got beat in Week 17. That’s the guy I want, because he learned and adapted. I wanted a coach who knew how to make changes to win. The Giants defense improved by leaps and bounds in a month and a half that year.
www.rhunekincaid.com
by YouAreSignedIn on Oct 26, 2010 5:23 PM MDT up reply actions
It would've made sense to hire a defensive coordinator as head coach after firing an offensive guru.
When I heard McDaniels was tapped to be the guy, I had an odd feeling about what was going to come next. And I wasn’t particularly pleased with it, either. The subsequent situations with Cutler, Marshall and Scheffler didn’t exactly help things on that front, either.
You’ll look at my signature and see that, yes, I’m a St. Louis area native. Which means I get to see the Rams just about every week, whether I like it or not (and from about the last few years up until the last month or so, that team had been an unmitigated disaster to watch on both sides of the ball).
It didn’t hurt that the team had already in their possession a few playmakers on both sides of the ball (and when I say that, I look at the likes of Oshiomogho Atogwe on defense and Steven Jackson on offense). But what was missing was a system, and Spagnuolo has implemented a system on defense and allowed Pat Shurmur to do the same on offense, along the way giving him a stud quarterback in Sam Bradford to complement a young stable of receivers and one of the best all-purpose running backs in the game in Jackson. The best thing I’ve seen out of that team is a lack of egos, which considering Jackson’s past craziness is quite an accomplishment. Plus, quotes coming out of their devastating one-point loss to the Bucs yesterday show that they really were stung by that loss, a game they for all intents and purposes dominated in every phase except the scoreboard.
So yeah, I also wanted Spagnuolo as the coach in Denver. Perhaps with him, Elvis Dumervil would’ve never been moved to Outside Linebacker and become a dominant force on the pass rush last season. That said, would Jamaal Charles have run for eleventy-billion yards (or however many it was) in Week 17 last year? I’d like to hope not. He would’ve had some pieces to work with, and Shurmur would’ve had a pretty stout offensive line and a few skill guys to work with as well.
Yesterday’s game was a disaster, and something that should never happen on Raider Week. NEVER. EVER. But it happened, and we have to deal with it. Hindsight is always 20-20, and if somehow, someway the Broncos are able to turn it around, I’ll be one of the first to congratulate McDaniels and his staff for the job they did in helping turn it around. Until then, it looks like there were some bad decisions made in that 2009 offseason. And it’s never easy to correct one bad decision, much less several.
St. Louis Game Time . . . I need another beer.
And I can also write things in 140 characters or fewer.
Yeah, I had a bad feeling about him because he’d just come from guiding a completely stacked offense. I think I could win a few games if I had Tom Brady in the pocket with plenty of time to find Randy Moss and Wes Welker.
Now that he’s here and I get a look at his ego, I’m even ore nervous. Hopefully, his bullheadedness will get him succesful or fired.
www.rhunekincaid.com
Well actually
he’d just come from guiding Matt Cassel, who hadn’t started a game since high school, to an 11-5 record. I’m not saying that in and of itself makes him an elite HC prospect, especially given his track record so far here. But a lot of people were impressed.
He’s really solid on paper and in his philosophy, but he seems to have real problems translating it on Sunday, and that, of course, is what ultimately matters.
by Broncologist on Oct 26, 2010 11:44 PM MDT up reply actions
Another great WHAT IF?
What if, Bowlen hired Spag and we kept developing Cutler/Hillis/Marshall/Sheffler, etc.? We build a strong Defense and let Shanny’s Offense be? What if, we kept Shanny and let him develop his high powered offense and continue to piece-meal together a defense? Well, neither happened, neither would have guaranteed success and I believe Pat Bowlen knew that. He knew McD was young & lacked valuable experience, but all choices in this business are filled with risks. In the end, I think McD will become who Bowlen thinks he will, the “kid” has shown spark & moxy in the midst of this learning process. It has been painful for fans, but I think Bowlen was prepared for it, hence his lack of comment over the season. Let’s hope he was right and a new golden era awaits us around the corner! GO BRONCOS!







































