Alphonso Smith and the Wisdom of 2nd Round picks

Amidst all the talk of the Alphonso Smith trade(s), there is one constant- we continue to refer to his pick as having been a first rounder.  And that is close to the truth, in that we traded away our 2010 first round pick (#14) in order to use the #37 pick of the 2009 draft to take him.  However, that does NOT equate to having used a first round pick on Alphonso Smith.  It equates to having traded a first round pick, and then used a 2nd round pick to select him.  This seemingly unimportant distinction, however, carries a lot of weight.  Follow me after the break...

Most probably won't remember, but in the days leading up to the Brandon Marshall trade, once we knew he was going to be traded and the question was simply what we would get back, I predicted that we would end up with two 2nd round picks as compensation.  This obviously ended up becoming the case.  So how did I know that McXanders would specifically want to bring in 2nd round picks?  The key is value.


If you look at New England's draft strategies for the past decade, you will notice an interesting trend.  Here are NE's picks in the first 3 rounds beginning in 2000-


2.15 OL  Adrian Klemm  Hawaii   
3.14 RB  J.R. Redmond  Arizona State



1.06 DL  Richard Seymour  Georgia   
2.17 OL  Matt Light  Purdue   
3.24 DB  Brock Williams  Notre Dame



1.21 TE  Daniel Graham  Colorado   
2.33 WR  Deion Branch  Louisville



1.13 DL  Ty Warren  Texas A&M  from CHI; trade drafts picks 2003 1.14 and 6.20 (was from NYJ; trade draft pick 2003 1.04 plus rec'd 2003 1.22 and 4.19 (was from WAS; compensation WR Laveranues Coles))
2.04 DB  Eugene Wilson  Illinois  from HOU; trade draft picks 2003 2.09 and 3.11 plus rec'd 2003 4.20
2.13 WR  Bethel Johnson  Texas A&M  from CAR; trade draft picks 2003 2.18 and 4.23



1.21 DL  Vince Wilfork  Miami  from BAL; trade draft pick BAL used to select QB Kyle Boller (2003)
1.32 TE  Ben Watson  Georgia   
2.31 DL  Marquise Hill  Louisiana State   
3.32 DB  Guss Scott  Florida   



1.32 OL  Logan Mankins  Fresno State   
3.20 DB  Ellis Hobbs  Iowa State  from BAL; trade picks 2005 2.32 plus rec'd draft pick 2005 6.21, 2006 3rd Round (TBD)
3.37 OL  Nick Kaczur  Toledo  compensatory pick



1.21 RB  Laurence Maroney  Minnesota   
2.04 WR  Chad Jackson  Florida  from GB; trade 2006 2.20, 3.11
3.22 TE  David Thomas  Texas   



1.24 DB  Brandon Meriweather  Miami  from SEA



1.10 LB  Jerod Mayo  Tennessee  from NO
2.31 DB  Terrence Wheatley  Colorado   
3.15 LB  Shawn Crable  Michigan  from NO
3.31 QB  Kevin O'Connell  San Diego State   



2.02 DB  Patrick Chung  Oregon  from KC
2.08 DL  Ron Brace  Boston College  from OAK
2.09 DB  Darius Butler  Connecticut  from GB
2.26 OL  Sebastian Vollmer  Houston   
3.19 WR  Brandon Tate  North Carolina  from NYJ through GB
3.33 LB  Tyrone McKenzie  South Florida  compensatory pick



1.27 DB  Devin McCourty  Rutgers  from DAL
2.10 TE  Rob Gronkowski  Arizona  from CHI through TB and OAK
2.21 DL  Jermaine Cunningham  Florida   
2.30 LB  Brandon Spikes  Florida  from MIN through HOU
3.26 WR  Taylor Price  Ohio  from DAL


# of 1st round picks- 10

# of 2nd round picks- 13

# of 3rd round picks- 11


So what does list this tell us?  First, NE is clearly targeting 2nd round picks to acquire in their trades.  And this is particularly the case over the past few years.  However, it is also striking that NE has only 3 picks in 11 years in the upper half of the 1st round.  Granted they have been an excellent team, but they have had high picks (acquired in trades) that they have generally relinquished (other than in 2001 and 2008 (in 2003 they actually moved back to the 13th pick from the 4th)).  So what is their draft strategy, and how does that apply to Alphonso Smith?

Clearly, they, and McX, are focused on value.  In the 1st round, and particularly the upper half of the round, the prices paid to rookies are exhorbitant.  However, beginning in the latter half of the 1st round, and continuing into the 2nd, the prices fall incredibly quickly.  By the time you reach the latter half of the 2nd round, the salaries for players become essentially the same, excepting signing bonus. 

One can easily make the analogy to a fantasy football draft.  In a FF draft, there will be the few elite players that cost tremendously to acquire (in draft pick terminology).  However, after the first half of a round or so, the talent levels off significantly to the point where the next 10-15 players will often have roughly the same worth.  However, they still must be selected in order, and if this were the NFL, the players selected highest would be paid exponentially more than those selected last.  In fact, the range is extreme- although one could argue the relative merits of the 10-15 players, in terms of worth they are all very similarly valued.  Yet, by nature of the in-order selection process, the players selected highest will make exponentially more money than those selected last.  So there becomes a severe disconnect between cost and worth. 

And this value discrepancy is at the heart of the NE/ McX draft strategy.  Rather than pay higher prices for relatively equal talent, trade into the area of the draft with the greatest value ratio (latter part of 1st- end of 2nd) and choose players from that range.  Then even if the players don't work out, there will be much less sunk cost, and more capital will be freed to improve the team elsewhere (FA, etc.). 

So, in discussing Alphonso Smith, it is actually very important to remember that we TRADED a 1st round pick to acquire him, but did not SELECT him with a 1st round pick.  Although this makes no difference in draft pick terms, it makes a tremendous difference in $ terms.  Because we actually made a much smaller $ investment in Smith than if we had used a 1st round pick to select him, we saved quite a bit of money that can be used to address other roster shortcomings.  So in essence, the trade becomes


2010 1st round pick (#14) for

2009 2nd round pick (#37) AND $


$ can then become FAs which help our team win a championship.  See the distinction?


(btw, this post is by no means an attempt to defend the particular selection of Smith, simply to defend the general strategy of targeting and acquiring 2nd round picks)

This is a Fan-Created Comment on The opinion here is not necessarily shared by the editorial staff of MHR

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Mile High Report

You must be a member of Mile High Report to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Mile High Report. You should read them.

Join Mile High Report

You must be a member of Mile High Report to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Mile High Report. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.