MHR Denver Broncos Hall of Fame Committee - Will Shannon Sharpe Be Inducted?
Over the past year, the MHR Hall of Fame Committee has been communicating with voters and getting the word out about Shannon Sharpe's historic career and we come bearing good news. We'll get to that in a moment. First, let's provide a little bit of groundwork for those who aren't familiar with the Hall of Fame induction process.
The 15 Hall of Fame finalists are as follows:
Jerome Bettis
Tim Brown
Chris Carter
Dermontti Dawson
Richard Dent
Chris Doleman
Marshall Faulk
Charles Haley
Chris Hanburger (senior committee finalist)
Cortez Kennedy
Curtis Martin
Andre Reed
Les Richter (senior committee finalist)
Willie Roaf
Ed Sabol
Deion Sanders
Shannon Sharpe
Between 4 and 7 finalists will be chosen to be enshrined into the Hall of Fame. An 80% majority vote from the Hall of Fame committee is required to be inducted. If more than 7 finalists receive an 80% majority vote, then only the top 7 vote-getters will be enshrined into the Hall of Fame. If fewer than 4 finalists receive an 80% majority vote, then the top 4 vote-getters will be enshrined into the Hall of Fame.
That last scenario isn't likely to happen this year.
There are so many quality names on the list and I doubt that the committee will be hurting to reach 4 candidates. The challenge will be narrowing them down from 15.
The second thing you need to know is why Shannon Sharpe wasn't inducted in 2010. To answer that question, I'll show you an excerpt from an email that the MHR HOF Committee received from one of the NFL Hall of Fame voters. For privacy's sake, I'll just submit the statement.
In giving the nod to Russ Grimm, Rickey Jackson, John Randle, Jerry Rice and Emmitt Smith for induction, we on the 44-member committee left behind six all-decade performers: wide receivers Tim Brown and Cris Carter, tight end Shannon Sharpe, running back Roger Craig, center Dermontti Dawson and defensive tackle Cortez Kennedy.
They return to the queue in 2011 and will be joined by first-time eligibles Deion Sanders, Marshall Faulk, Jerome Bettis, Curtis Martin and Willie Roaf.
So, the ballot for the Class of 2011 will include two of the top five rushers of all time (Bettis and Martin), two of the top five receivers of all time (Carter and Brown), a couple of eight-time Pro Bowlers (Kennedy and Sharpe), the usual assortment of all-decade performers (Craig, Dawson, Roaf, Sanders, Chris Doleman, Terrell Davis, Aeneas Williams) plus Charles Haley and his five Super Bowl rings.
Remember that the committee can only enshrine five modern era candidates at a time.
Of those candidates that the voter listed in the email, Sanders, Faulk, Bettis, Martin, Roaf, Carter, Brown, Sharpe, Kennedy, Dawson, Doleman and Haley are finalists for the Hall of fame. That email was from June, by the way. This means that the voter has successfully predicted 12 of the 15 finalists.
But we, as Broncos fans, want to know what the chances are for Shannon Sharpe this year. Right?
Well, the MHR Hall of Fame Committee asked that question. Here are a couple responses.
Shannon will get in. I don't think there's any question that he's a Hall of Famer. Whether it's in 2011 or 2012 or some other year, I can't predict.
There is no reason he hasn't made it other than it's not his time yet. It will be soon.
I would say sometime in the next three years.
I think Shannon Sharpe should make it and I believe he eventually will. Right now he's part of a group of candidates where there is a backlog that will be rectified over the next couple years.
As you can see, even a handful of Hall of Fame voters believe that Shannon Sharpe deserves to be in the Hall of Fame. The problem, however, is the voting system. There are just far too many Hall of Fame caliber candidates and too few spots for induction. It's a numbers game, not a talent game.
There's no question that Shannon Sharpe will get in. The question is... will this be the year?
Hall of Fame Class of 2011 Announcement: The Committee will begin meeting this Saturday, with the announcement to be broadcasted later that day on NFL Network at 7:00PM EST. Have your browser locked to MileHighReport all day for up to the second coverage. Be sure to follow MHR on Twitter as well - @MileHighReport
The Path of the MHR Hall of Fame Committee: Early last year the 2009 Pro Football Hall of Fame class was announced, and once again there were no Broncos inducted. There was anger and outrage, it was called a travesty, then it was called a travesty again. It was out of those posts a committee was born. No more weeping and gnashing of teeth, we're taking action. With John (Guru) advising and great help from Tim (Zappa), a committee consisting of Jezru, studbucket, and firstfan was formed with the purpose gathering data and opinions to create an organized campaign to get more Broncos in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. To see the first post in this series, go here. The second post can be found here. The third from November 2009, can be found here. After the successful campaign for Floyd Little and the celebratory post from here, here, and here, the committee passed the torch to a new slate of members. Bfree2bronc, broncosmontana and Troy (kentuckybronco) became the new faces of the committee. The mission continues. The walls of the Hall of Fame will be painted orange and blue.
31 comments
|
8 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Good stuff, thanks!
Because I’m lazy, I’ll just copy my comment over from the other thread. I think your communications with voters somewhat confirms my suspicions.
Ever since my work on the MHR HOF Committee I’ve had a better grasp on the HOF and its process. Given that, I have the following things to say:
1) Sharpe totally deserves to get in.
2) Sharpe totally will get in.
3) It may not be this year.
4) Somebody will get in this year that will make you angry. Maybe it’s Andre Reed, maybe it’s Richard Dent.
5) It’s a strong class again this year, and Ed Sabol is gaining a lot of momentum.
If I were to predict a HoF class?
1) Deion Sanders
2) Marshall Faulk
3) Ed Sabol
4) Richard Dent
5) Cris Carter
Although Andre Reed may inexplicably work his way into the class. I also sure hope Dent, Bettis, or Haley don’t make it.
Tweeting via @jtkimbell
I think it does, as well.
I was about to reply to your comment in the other thread but I knew I should save some of the quotes for this post. lol
I definitely agree with some of your predictions. I don’t think anyone will argue the Deion Sanders prediction. He is definitely a lock. The other four (or three if you consider Faulk a lock) are where you’ll get some debate. I think they’re all up in the air. I guess it all depends on what kind of mood the voters are in. There’s a bunch of ways to approach the vote.
So, you never know. That communication with voters definitely opened my eyes to some of the different tactics they approach the voting with. Of course, you have that experience with that, as well, so you know exactly what I mean.
The ignorant redneck formerly known as kentuckybronco.
by Troy Hufford on Feb 4, 2011 8:36 AM MST up reply actions 1 recs
I've heard that there is stout resistance on Ed Sabol....
Since he never played…. That said, it would be a shame not to recognize him for immortalizing and recording the game’s history as he did… That said, I don’t know about the precident that it sets… Does that mean the Steve Sabol gets considered in a few years? What about Ernie Ernst (the cameraman that perfected the slo mo spiraling ball in flight)? I think Sharpe gets is before Sabol does.
I’ve also heard rumors that Jeff Legwold is going all out in his presentation for Sharpe this year (a DP writer said something about it on twitter). I got fingers crossed that this is his year.
J
I definitely agree with that.
Sabol has been a surprise. Nobody saw him coming this far. We held most of our discussions during the summer time and then off and on during the fall… I don’t think his name came up even one time.
I think Sabol deserves to be in, but I don’t think he’ll get this year. Shannon definitely deserves to be in before Sabol.
I didn’t hear about Leggy pitching Sharpe. Hopefully, he does Shannon justice. I’m sure he will. He has a lot of resources to make a good pitch.
The ignorant redneck formerly known as kentuckybronco.
Sabol is really a troubling exception, in my mind
I love and appreciate the man beyond belief. Without him, as Schefter tweeted (or RT’d) the other day, we’d be writing about the greats, not watching them.
However….. I’m not a fan of the idea that media personas could end up in the HOF, and I’m afraid that’s the door that would be getting cracked here. Can you imagine John Clayton getting in someday? I know that’s an extreme idea, but if Sabol is in it’s going to open the door to a lot of arguments I don’t think we should be having. IMO, we need some form of honorarium that can be bestowed on people who have made an outstanding contribution to football without giving them a bust.
Walking into that hall in Canton is an amazing experience. Entering the room with the busts is tremendously emotional. But from my perspective, one of the things that makes it unique is that everyone there is either a player or an owner — someone who had a direct impact on the game on the field. As much as I admire Sabol’s profound contributions, I just can’t support him being in there instead of one of the greats he documented. Which is really what this boils down to.
Bringing you hopeful optimism and irreverent naivité, 24/7. GO BRONCOS!
by broncosmontana on Feb 4, 2011 8:59 PM MST up reply actions 1 recs
hell
give them their own wing, The Ed Sabol NFL Media Studies Center or something.
Bringing you hopeful optimism and irreverent naivité, 24/7. GO BRONCOS!
by broncosmontana on Feb 4, 2011 9:07 PM MST up reply actions
Okay and here's another way to think about it....
Concerning the story about how Ed became involved with the NFL, I’m not entirely sure that what he did was a unique thing meritous of sitting next to John Elway and John Madden.
To excerpt the blurb from wikipedia:
He founded Blair Motion Pictures in 1962. Its first major contract was to film the 1962 NFL Championship Game between the New York Giants and the Green Bay Packers at Yankee Stadium in New York. In 1964, Blair Motion Pictures became NFL Films, with an exclusive deal to preserve NFL games on film. It has been said by his son Steve Sabol, of NFL Films, “The only other human endeavor more thoroughly captured on 16-mm film than the National Football League is World War II.”
He was essentially a guy that won a contract to exclusively produce films of every game it was people he hired that did innovated within the work to give it that unique look – Ernie Ernst (station of the cross) and even Steve Sabol. Who’s to say that if Blair Films had lost out to Tootie or Joe Films that the natural filmic progression wouldn’t have happened without his leadership? To quote the “Lost Treasures”, the early NFL Films looked like coaching film – wide shots without closeups or even audio. It was the technicians hired by Sabol (and that could have been hired by whoever else was awarded the contract) that brought in the slow motion and the closeups of the feet and faces that created the brand that is NFL films (heck, according to Ed himself the slow motion that we know today is a result of an accident that he himself had nothing to do with other than to say – “hey that looks kinda cool, let’s do more of that”). Who is to say that the innovations wouldn’t have evolved at the same rate with someone else at the helm – considering it was the medium being filmed that ultimate let to the devising of those innovatoins.
I am, of course, over simplifying here and as kind of window dressing to what you say above. To let Ed Sabol in as though he were a player, coach or owner opens the door to everyone who is associated with the NFL in broadcast/production and even web design (should we immortalize the CBSSPORTS as the first web designer of NFL.com?). What about John Facenta? People know him more than they know Ed Sabol. It’s a can of worms and I don’t like it. No sir. I’ll take my Shannon Sharpe and won’t make any noise…
Until next year…
J
well said!
John Facenta is next. Bank it.
Bringing you hopeful optimism and irreverent naivité, 24/7. GO BRONCOS!
by broncosmontana on Feb 5, 2011 9:32 PM MST up reply actions
I have a feeling he wont- which is a crime
Last year I emailed a voter asking why he didnt vote for Sharpe and his response was that his numbers weren’t that impressive for a WR, I pushed harder saying he held every significant TE record when he retired and 3 superbowl rings, and he told me that he felt he was a WR and not a TE so he would not be voting for him.
Could be.
There are a handful of voters that do feel that way, which is ridiculous. That seems to be the one crowd that will not vote for Shannon. Either the voters think he definitely deserves in or they judge him as a WR and say he’s not going to get their vote….. Good thing it doesn’t have to be unanimous.
The ignorant redneck formerly known as kentuckybronco.
It's Ridiculous
Not sure why some voters feel that way. None of the guys I was able to email with last year felt that way, luckily. I know Howard Balzer said that was stupid and guaranteed Sharpe would get in.
Of course, they’re all doing that, they’re just taking their sweet time getting him in.
Tweeting via @jtkimbell
I know it's not an official site
but the Fan’s Choice website has the following order:
- Darryl Talley
- Andre Reed
- Steve Tasker
- Kent Hull
- Fred Smerlas
Sounds like the Buffalo crowd has nothing better to do when they’re snowed in!
"It's all over Fat Man" - Tom Jackson to John Madden 1977 AFC Championship Game
RIP Barrel Man - 12/5/09
Fan's Choice Makes NO FREAKING SENSE to me
I don’t get the point. It affects nothing, it’s less accurate than Pro Bowl voting, and I’ve found that people are extraordinarily ignorant when it comes to the HOF, the process, and the qualifications of players, so you’re bound to have nothing but idiocy.
I follow the Fan’s Choice on Twitter, but I probably shouldn’t, it’s not good for my blood pressure.
Tweeting via @jtkimbell
Steve Tasker
is NOT a hall of famer. You can’t convince me otherwise.
Which one doesn’t belong: Starr, Elway, Marino, Montana, Dawson, Tasker
J
I so agree
Bringing you hopeful optimism and irreverent naivité, 24/7. GO BRONCOS!
by broncosmontana on Feb 4, 2011 9:50 PM MST up reply actions
My Picks
There won’t be two RBs picked at the same time, there won’t be two WRs picked at the same time and certainly not two WRs and a TE thought to be a WR, there will be a lineman, there will be a defender, there will be a surprise.
With those parameters, I predict:
Shannon Sharpe
Cris Carter
Deion Sanders
Marshall Faulk
Dermonti Dawson
I would be very happy with that class
And it’s what I want to happen. Unfortunately, I don’t expect what I want to happen to actually happen.
Tweeting via @jtkimbell
I'll take that one.
Both Sharpe and Carter should already be in.
Floyd Little: HOF Class of 2010.
2009-10 back-to-back NBA Champions L.A Lakers
2009-10 NBA Finals MVP Kobe Bryant
Shannon
Rod Smith
TD
RANDY effing GRADISHAR!
….sigh…..
- Nick
"Know the enemy, know yourself, and victory is never in doubt, not in a hundred battles."
- Sun Tzu
"And I mean that in the most professional way possible."
- Brandon Lloyd
by ncm42 on Feb 4, 2011 9:33 AM MST reply actions 1 recs
I know I'm beating a dead.....errrrmmmm....
But Gradishar is one of the single biggest examples of a “crime of omission.” I’ve said it repeatedly…put him and his numbers in Chicago, Green Bay, or NY, and people are talking “best ever.” It’s ridiculous.
Oh, and since he is the actual topic of this post, Shannon and Tony Gonzalez both have an argument for being the best TE ever, but Shannon set the stage for TG.
- Nick
"Know the enemy, know yourself, and victory is never in doubt, not in a hundred battles."
- Sun Tzu
"And I mean that in the most professional way possible."
- Brandon Lloyd
Oh, and since he is the actual topic of this post, Shannon and Tony Gonzalez both have an argument for being the best TE ever, but Shannon set the stage for TG.
My sentiment EXACTLY! If Shannon hadn’t come along and essentially redefined the position, Tony G would most likely have been a WR. Shannon Sharpe made guys like Gonzales, Gates, Stocky, and Heap possible. He is the link between the old school greats and the new school greats. It would have happened eventually, this evolution, but it was actually embodied in Shannon Sharpe.
Bringing you hopeful optimism and irreverent naivité, 24/7. GO BRONCOS!
by broncosmontana on Feb 4, 2011 8:52 PM MST up reply actions 1 recs
10?
Why not, for one year only, open it up to 10 inductees just to catch up on this backlog that everyone acknowledges?
From the noise around the net
He’s likely to get in. NFL.com did a survey of their analysts, besides Faulk and Sanders, the two 100% guys, Sharpe tied for the 3rd spot, and won the fan poll of who should get in. I see no reason he should get in, all the analysts I’ve read say he’s on of their top choices. And considering he gets more media face time then Reed, Carter, Tez, Dent or Bettis, I don’t think fans should be claiming conspiracy just yet.
My HoF votes:
Sharpe
Faulk
Sanders
Tez Kennedy
Dent
Now this class is to good to let guys like Dent and Tez in, but they deserve it just as much as Sharpe.
I am a bear of very little brains and big words bother me.
As much as I dislike using the analysts to get a feel for the vote... I gravitate towards it in this case.
Maybe it’s that optimist inside me that yearns for more optimism. I don’t know. I just hope he gets in.
The ignorant redneck formerly known as kentuckybronco.
by Troy Hufford on Feb 4, 2011 12:20 PM MST up reply actions
I suppose I trust analysts more then fan voting
I am a bear of very little brains and big words bother me.
This time, yes... but I have a hard time thinking that Jamie Dukes is more intelligent than anyone - fans included.
Just my opinion. :)
The ignorant redneck formerly known as kentuckybronco.
No way Tez gets in on first ballot
Having CC and Reed on the same ballot probably splits their vote; my prediction is:
Tim Brown
Deion Sanders
Richard Dent
Marshall Faulk
Ed Sabol
although I wouldn’t be surprised if Curtis Martin sneaks in there, there’s a lot of NY guys to vote.
I realize Tez isn't getting in this class
It’s too strong, but he deserves to get in.
I am a bear of very little brains and big words bother me.
Definitely Does
Although it’s not his first ballot, he’s been here for a while.
Also, I strongly disagree with all the folks who think Dent is a Hall-of-Famer, but I realize several people think I’m crazy.
Tweeting via @jtkimbell

by 







































