Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Rob Ryan Talks About The Cowboys' Secondary

Quarterback Sack Costs For the Broncos (and the League) in 2011

In the final installment of the starting Salaries series, I present the cost of a Quarterback Sack for the Denver Broncos as well as the rest of the league. I will attempt to show the 3 main pass rushing threats for each team last year, or at least the three players who accumulated the most in their Sack attack. Then we will look at what percentage of their teams Sacks they contributed and finally what was the price tag for a Sack for each team. This will help us understand how the Salaries for Pass Rushers have escalated and who got the best value for their buck. The values may be skewed a little because of the players out performing their rookie contracts, but to me, that makes a statement on the talent evaluators in each teams Scouting staff.

Star-divide

I will break it down for you in order to understand the chart. The teams are listed by their Sack total for 2011 from most to the least. The three main Sack contributors for each team are next with their contributions in parentheses. After that is the percentage of their team's Total Sacks (%of SKS), the total Salaries of those three contributors in 2011(2011 Cost in Millions) and what each Sack from those three players cost their team (Value in Thousands). Then I ranked each team according to the cost per Sack, from the lowest to the highest, their projected 2012 expense (at present time) and any Free Agents they must deal with.

Team SK Top 3 Sack men (2011 Sacks) % of SKs 2011 Cost Value Rank 2012 Cost Notes
Philadelphia Eagles 50 Jason Babin (18),Trent Cole (11),Cullen Jenkins (5.5) 69 8.77 254K 12 19.34
Minnesota Vikings 50 Jared Allen (22),Brian Robison (8),Kevin Williams (5) 70 15.67 448K 24 15.65
New York Giants 48 Jason Pierre-Paul (16.5),Osi Umentiora (9),Justin Tuck (5) 63.5 7.05 93K 2 8
Baltimore Ravens 48 Terrell Suggs (14), Pernell McPhee (6), Paul Kruger (5.5)</td> 53.1 4.425 174K 10 6.01
Cincinnati Bengals 45 Geno Atkins (7.5),Jonathan Fanene (6.5),Michael Johnson (6) 44.4 2.085 105K 3 1.055 Jonathan Fanene: UFA
Houston Texans 44 Connor Barwin (11.5),Antonio Smith (6.5),Brooks Reed (6) 54.5 6.25 261K 13 7.24
Dallas Cowboys 42 DeMarcus Ware (19.5),Anthony Spencer (6),Jason Hatcher (4.5) 71.4 8.4 280K 14 6.5 Anthony Spencer: UFA
Arizona Cardinals 42 Calais Campbell (8),Sam Acho (7),Daryl Washington (5) 47.6 6.25 313K 17 0.955 Calais Campbell:UFA
San Francisco 49ers 42 Aldon Smith (14),Justin Smith (7.5),Ahmad Brooks (7) 67.8 9.79 344K 21 9.4 Ahmad Brooks: UFA
Washington Redskins 41 Brian Orakpo (9),Ryan Kerrigan (7.5),Stephen Bowen (6) 54.8 3.85 171K 7 4.44
Detroit Lions 41 Cliff Avril (11),Kyle Vanden Bosch (8),Lawrence Jackson (4.5) 57.3 7.82 333K 20 5.92 Cliff Avril: UFA
Miami Dolphins 41 Cameron Wake (8.5),Jason Taylor (7),Jared Odrick (6) 52.4 1.98 922K 30 1.13 Jason Taylor (retiring)
Denver Broncos 41 Von Miller (11.5),Elvis Dumervil (9.5),D.J. Williams (5) 63.4 24.15 929K 31 24.25
New England Patriots 40 Mark Anderson (10),Andre Carter (10),Rob Ninkovich (6.5) 66.2 3.08 116K 4 0 All 3 are UFA's
St. Louis Rams 39 Chris Long (13),James Hall (6),Robert Quinn (5) 61.5 4.96 207K 11 6.11
Oakland Raiders 39 Tommy Kelly (7.5),Kamerion Wimbley (7),Richard Seymour (6) 52.5 25.5 1.25M 32 24.5
Pittsburgh Steelers 35 James Harrison (9),LaMarr Woodley (9),Jason Worilds (3) 60 2.75 131K 5 9.2
New York Jets 35 Aaron Maybin (6),David Harris (5),Bart Scott (4.5) 44.3 6.42 414K 23 15.5 Aaron Maybin: RFA
Seattle Seahawks 33 Chris Clemons (11),Leroy Hill (4),Alan Branch (3) 54.5 5.48 305K 16 6 Leroy Hill: UFA
New Orleans Saints 33 Roman Harper (7.5),Will Smith (6.5),Junior Galette (4.5) 56.1 8.3 448K 25 14.61
Chicago Bears 33 Julius Peppers (11),Henry Melton (7),Israel Idonije (5) 69.7 13.38 582K 27 9.46 Israel Idonije: UFA
Atlanta Falcons 33 John Abraham (9.5),Sean Weatherspoon (4),Ray Edwards (3.5) 51.5 11.4 671K 28 6.73 John Abraham: UFA
Cleveland Browns 32 Jabaal Sheard (8.5),Ahtyba Rubin (5),Phil Taylor (4) 54.7 3 171K 8 6.84
San Diego Chargers 32 Antwan Barnes (11),Cam Thomas (4),Shaun Phillips (3.5) 57.8 5.9 319K 18 6.49
Carolina Panthers 31 Charles Johnson (9),Greg Hardy and Thomas Keiser (4) 54.8 4.78 281K 15 5.7
Jacksonville Jaguars 31 Jeremy Mincey (8),Daryl Smith and Matt Roth (3.5) 48.4 7.2 480K 26 4.7 Jeremy Mincey No $ for 2011, UFA in 2012. Matt Roth:UFA
Green Bay Packers 29 Clay Matthews (6),Desmond Bishop (5),Erik Walden (3) 48.3 2.4 171K 9 3.63 Erik Walden: UFA
Buffalo Bills 29 Marcell Dareus (5.5),Chris Kelsay (5),Nick Barnett (3) 46.5 4.37 324K 19 8.3
Indianapolis Colts 29 Robert Mathis (9.5),Dwight Freeney (8.5),Jamaal Anderson (3) 72.4 14.58 410K 22 14.03 Robert Mathis, Jamaal Anderson: UFAs
Kansas City Chiefs 29 Tamba Hali (12),Justin Houston (5.5),Wallace Gilberry (2.5) 68.9 14.53 727K 29 12.69 Wallace Gilberry: UFA
Tennessee Titans 28 Karl Klug (7),Dave Ball (4),Jason Jones (3) 50 2.23 159K 6 0.465 Dave Ball, Jason Jones: UFAs
Tampa Bay Buccaneers 23 Adrian Clayborn (7.5),Michael Bennett (4),Brian Price (3) 63 1.26 87K 1 1.24 Michael Bennett: RFA

As you can see, the Minnesota Vikings and the Philadelphia Eagles led the league in Sacking the Quarterback as a team in 2011. The Eagles got a better value since they only spent $254K per Sack, while the Vikes shelled out $448K. However, I believe that since they achieved 70% of that statistic with 3 players, that cost is worth it. Obviously each team will be different in placing a priority on the Sack statistic and the money allotted to that. The Green Bay Packers for instance, rely on a greater part of their Defensive personnel to contain and pressure the Quarterback, forcing a mistake by being patient and disciplined rather than forcing the issue with all out blitzes per se. Teams like the Pittsburgh Steelers, Indianapolis Colts and and the Denver Broncos balance their Pass rush with "Book ends," a pass rush specialist on each side of the line. Pittsburgh does it with Outside Linebackers James Harrison and LaMarr Woodley. The Colts have Defensive Ends Robert Mathis and Dwight Freeney and the Broncos use one of each, OLB Von Miller and DE Elvis Dumervil to wreak havoc on opposing Quarterbacks.

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers spent the least amount per Sack in 2011 at $87K. However, they also produced the least amount of Sacks. Is their ownership a Miser? Perhaps. perhaps not. They had 3 players on their rookie contracts producing their pressure and in their defense (no pun intended), Gerald McCoy will be back after a stay on the Injured Reserve List in 2011. I didn't include his salary in the 2012 projection.

The Denver Broncos outspent all but the Raiders for each Sack produced in 2011 at $929K per Sack. Their expense in 2012 rises very minimal, but the Denver Front Office has to be concerned with the production return on that investment. Sure, you could blame it on injuries. Elvis Dumervil was struggling with a shoulder injury in the early part of the season and finally returned to 100% a little past the halfway mark. Von Miller broke a thumb and lost one source of leverage, making him less effective. That is reason enough for me to think the Broncos 2011 Sack total of 41 will increase.

There are greater depths that can be derived from this list and maybe one of you will journey down that path to solve the questions of, which player was paid the highest per Sack and which team got the best value for an individual Pass Rusher? Another interesting question would be the correlation of Sacks to Wins and if that was that big of a factor?

I will leave that for you to ponder and discover if it leads you on that adventure.


Comment 15 comments  |  4 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Superbowl winners Giants are famous for their D-line

And they know how to draft D-line, too, as they have success in picking great productive DTs and DEs in the draft, so they don’t have to overpay. Denver, on the other hand, dig themselves into a hole.

by si_ice on Feb 7, 2012 1:29 PM MST reply actions   2 recs

I'm not so sure sack totals will rise

Doom is hurt more often than not these days. I hate to say it, but it’s a pretty safe bet to count on him missing games. Hopefully Miller returns to form. After his injury he was a shell of himself. It goes to show you what you get when maintaining a superb defensive line. Two Super Bowls in 4 years. I seriously hope EFX were taking notes. And it’s not like we, as fans, haven’t been clamoring for better line play for years. When do the guys getting paid to make those decisions figure it out?

Whatcha gonna do, brother, when the Broncos run wild on you!

by postpunk27 on Feb 7, 2012 1:52 PM MST reply actions   1 recs

dumervil

According to some stats sites, Dumervil, while ranked positively as a pass rusher, was rated higher as a run defender.

The bigger problem with our pass rush is that the other three folks on the line are all below par in pass rush, at least according to ProFootballFocus. Marcus Thomas is especially bad. They were all excellent at run defense, though.

I’m not so sure we want to get a DL player good at pass rush at the expense of run defense – better to draft someone highly that is good at both.

by tunesmith on Feb 7, 2012 2:11 PM MST up reply actions  

Just with the naked eye I thought Ryan McBean was the best pass rusher of the DT group...

I’m having a hard time believing we will draft a DT in the first round and may not the entire draft. EFX have a philosophy of building the team and whatever the media says has nothing to do with how they draft. People can rant all day long what EFX should do, but it just lands on deaf ears…

"You hate to think you have to censor your language to meet other people's lack of understanding" -Julian Bond

by bfree2bronc on Feb 7, 2012 2:29 PM MST up reply actions  

What?

I thought they read MHR everyday and took our thoughts to heart. You mean to say they don’t.

Believe you can and you're halfway there.
Theodore Roosevelt

by Digger24 on Feb 7, 2012 3:08 PM MST up reply actions  

My guess...

They go with the best player available philosophy again. There are still plenty of holes to fill and I don’t forsee them being overly aggressive in FA. So its possible we dont end up with a DT in the draft, but that doesn’t mean EFX didn’t do a good job. (Drafting another Rahim Moore / Mcbath might though)

by Triz06 on Feb 7, 2012 3:16 PM MST up reply actions  

oddly enough

we talk about the importance of pressuring the quarterback and I know it is essential but it’s funny that neither the Iggles or Vikings made the playoffs despite having 100 sacks between them

Brad James

Follow me on Twitter

With Coach Zorro on our side, we will slice opponents to ribbons. Tim Tebow gives me hope and I already have faith and charity in my heart! I see a propitious future rife with Lombardis for our Broncos!

by the new Bradfather on Feb 7, 2012 2:43 PM MST reply actions  

True brad that is funny.

Believe you can and you're halfway there.
Theodore Roosevelt

by Digger24 on Feb 7, 2012 3:09 PM MST up reply actions  

the funny part is the money.

Denver apparently spent 10 mil more than anyone else and didn’t come in last in price per sack

Playoffs!?!? Playoffs!?!? Don't talk about Playoffs!! Playoffs?!?!

by Mike Agnew on Feb 7, 2012 8:15 PM MST via mobile reply actions  

dumervil is 3rd on the list among guys who didn't lead their own team in sacks

Playoffs!?!? Playoffs!?!? Don't talk about Playoffs!! Playoffs?!?!

by Mike Agnew on Feb 7, 2012 8:18 PM MST via mobile reply actions  

Tampa

It’s strange #1 didn’t do better

by Baghdad on Feb 7, 2012 9:19 PM MST reply actions  

missing

Why do you only count production vs cost, this makes the data invalid. The most expensive lion lineman is suh and he goes unlisted. Any expensive free agent failures are exempt.

by Rugbythug on Feb 8, 2012 11:13 AM MST via mobile reply actions  

good point

Not sure how you fix it unless you simply look at total salary for the D-line/OLB position group, but then you get wierd problems where 4-3 DEFs tend to carry more Dlinemen, etc. But agree that this analysis misses by taking a wierd defintiion of the “top-3” players….

For example, is Roman Harper really the 3rd primary pass rusher for NOLA? I highly doubt it.

Same for DJ with us…. he’s really expensive, but his primary role is not rushing the passer…

ILB and DB guys like Harper and DJ typically gets sacks because of scheme and what their fellow D-line players are doing more than inate ability… subsitute pretty much any NFL player into their role in the DEF, and you’d likely get plus/minus-1 sack difference at most. For Denver, Ayers or McBean were clearly our “3rd” passrusher… pretty much any DE from either a 3-4 for 4-3 that gets significant 3rd down snaps should probably not be left out (even if they move inside to DT like Ayers does).

by cjfarls on Feb 8, 2012 1:58 PM MST up reply actions  

Because I already did that

Here.

This post was about the production vs. cost. I took the top 3 players with the most Sacks on each team. And yes there are players missing. Some were in the IR list. Feel free to do the weeks worth of research and explain it to me.

Character may be manifested in the great moments but it is made in the small ones -- Philip Brooks
My ship finally came in, but it was the Kobayashi Maru.

KaptainKirk on FaceBook

by KaptainKirk on Feb 8, 2012 4:52 PM MST up reply actions  

link

I read that. It does not mention any production. Just cost of position. I understand that it is a lot of work, however this example is flawed to the point of having no value.

by Rugbythug on Feb 9, 2012 1:12 AM MST via mobile reply actions   1 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

MileHighReport(MHR) is the ultimate independent resource for the Denver Broncos on the web. Along with MHR Radio, the official podcast of MHR, we look to provide hardcore Denver Broncos fans positive, independent insight about the Broncos, 24/7/365!

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Imgres_small
Running Backs, The Shortest Tenured Position.
P1_plummer_small
For those Bronco Fans Who have served....

Recent FanPosts

Broncos_small
Realistic Rookie Expectations
Small
Studying the Quarterback Position: Part Two
Small
Is Quantity, Quality? And The Sophomore Slump...
Small
Am I the only one with that feeling?
Small
Studying the Quarterback Position
Angels_small
Moreno Out the Door this Offseason
Small
What Do You Expect From Our Draftees ?
Small
An in depth look at "PLAN A"

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Getting Social With MHR

Facebook_badge_medium_medium
Black_generated_button

Milehighreport_email_medium

Web Stuff


 

Listed on BlogShares Top NFL Fan Sites


General Manager/Head Coach

Milehighreport_small John Bena

2011_small KaptainKirk

Asst. Head Coach

2_small Sayre Bedinger

Bronco-pride_small Brian Shrout

Broncohoodie_in_africa_small Troy Hufford

Img_0007_small Topher Doll

Position Coach

182px-jesus_small Jezru

Flag_canada_small Colby

Broncos-von-miller_small Scotty Payne

Ph_small BroncoPH

Small zsheely

Hottie_small Sarah_Marshall