clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Horse Tracks: Why don't NFL teams go for two more often?

New, comments

Dear Broncos, math says you should go for two more often. Love, Jon.

Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

Down 21-7 against the Patriots in the fourth quarter on Sunday, the Broncos scored a touchdown and kicked an extra point to make it 21-14. Standard procedure for such a situation. But what if they had been more aggressive?

Later in the game, Denver kicked a field goal from New England's three-yard line to make it 21-17. Had they converted two points after their fourth quarter touchdown, that field goal would have made it a one-field goal game.

Kyle explained his tweet later: converting for two points would have made it 21-15, a six point game. Scoring two field goals seemed more feasible than a touchdown at the time, and a failed two-point attempt would have made it 21-13, still just a one-possession game.

Going for two then and converting a field goal at the three-yard line later would have made the score 21-18, putting Denver down just one field goal. It wasn't necessarily a bad decision, and Denver went on to win the game anyway in thrilling fashion, 30-24 in overtime.

But going for two more often is a topic worth discussing.

This year, NFL teams have gone 775-of-820 on PATs (94 percent). They've gone 33-of-71 on two-point attempts (46 percent). That 46 percent may not seem to be very appealing, but it includes the teams that have been awful this year (the Bears are 2-of-5, the Saints are 0-of-3, and the Seahawks are 1-of-4). Granted, some NFL teams have been bad on PATs, too, but the math says teams should probably go for two more often.

On 71 PATs with a 94 percent success rate, teams would score 66 points. On 71 two-point attempts with a 46 percent success rate, teams would score 66 points. According to the math, you have nothing to lose by going for two.*

That's not necessarily, true, however, because there's obviously everything to lose. The game is on the line. Sometimes (when down one point with no time left, for example), going for two would be foolish. Teams don't always have to be gutsy, going for the win instead of overtime, but they could be more aggressive.

On average, the same amount of points are scored with two-point attempts, but there's potential to score more points.

If you're good at it, like the Steelers (6-of-9, 66 percent), on 71 attempts you'll score 92 points. That's 26 more points than 71 PATs at the league average. You have to score more points than the other team to win, so 26 additional points should sound appealing.

Denver is among ten teams that have been perfect on PATs this year (25-of-25), with Brandon McManus deserving of much credit. They're 0-of-1 on two-point attempts. So why fix what's not broken, you ask?

Because I'm greedy. I like scoring points. I like scoring more points than the other team. I go for two nearly every time in Madden (not a fair comparison to real life, I know). I'd go for two in real life, too, more often than not. There's not much to lose, and there's everything to gain.

More points wins games, and winning is awesome.

Note I: This post was written before the completion of MNF, so PAT and two-point figures do not include last night's totals. PAT and two-point numbers were taken from

*Note II: If you don't round the percentages, you'd score about half a point more on 71 kicks, but they both add up to about 66 points.

Horse Tracks

Peyton Manning won’t be back "anytime soon"

According to ESPN’s Chris Mortensen, Manning won’t be playing "anytime soon."

T.J. Ward, Sly Williams expected to miss a week with injuries for Broncos

The Broncos are bracing for strong safety T.J. Ward and nose tackle Sylvester Williams to miss Sunday's game against the San Diego Chargers and possibly against the Oakland Raiders the next week.

MRI shows no tears in right knee of Patriots TE Rob Gronkowski

An MRI showed that New England Patriots tight end Rob Gronkowski has a bruised right knee but no tears, a source told ESPN's Dianna Russini on Monday.

Patriots cut Chris Harper following muffed punt

Chris Harper has been banished from the New England Patriots' roster following Sunday night's costly muffed punt. Harper was released on Monday, the team announced.

You may soon be able buy stock in Vernon Davis, apparently

Fantex has purchased a percentage of future earnings in these athletes. Contract and endorsement money will come into the company in the form of revenues. When the athlete retires, appearance fees and broadcasting contracts are included in the deals.

Broncos enjoy winter weather in win over Patriots

Despite the fact they make their in-season home 5,280 feet above sea level with world-class skiing just up the interstate and have seen a Mother’s Day snowstorm more than a few times, or perhaps on Halloween as well, many of the Denver Broncos haven’t played many games in the fluffy stuff.

9 reasons why the Broncos beat the Patriots

I re-watched the Denver Broncos' 30-24 overtime victory against the New England Patriots. Here's why the Broncos won:

Von Miller fires back at Tom Brady on Instagram

If you’re going to do that, Brady, you better make sure you walk home with a victory. Through 10 games, he was able to do just that, but not last night; Von Miller made sure to remind him of that.

Broncos buck off Pats' Tom Brady on field and Facebook

Before playing the Denver Broncos Sunday night, New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady posted a photo of himself on Facebook riding a bucking bronco.

Kubiak "real concerned" about the number of hits Osweiler has been taking

Now that an injury to Peyton Manning has opened the door for quarterback Brock Osweiler, the Broncos don’t want the door to be slammed shut repeatedly on Osweiler’s leg.

Peyton Manning's return may depend on when cast is removed this week

The biggest question in the Broncos' near future remains Peyton Manning's health and potential return from a partially torn left plantar fascia.

Tom Brady: I've never been so visibly pissed after loss

"It was a very hard loss," Brady told WEEI's The Dennis and Callahan Show on Monday. "I don't think I've ever been so visibly pissed off after a loss. And I think everyone felt the same way. Hopefully we can use it as motivation going forward. Like I said, there's things that we could have done better. And it's certainly not to leave it up to a call here or a call there or one player. There's things across the board that we need to do a better job of and we can do a better job of. And that's what the focus is going to be this week."

Was the Broncos hit that injured Rob Gronkowski a dirty play?

Towering tight end Rob Gronkowski, Tom Brady’s most-targeted receiver Sunday against the Broncos, was carted off the field late in the fourth quarter with a knee injury. He didn’t return. But was the play that put him down "dirty"?

After Gronk knee injury, Brady says rules force low hits

"I don’t think it’s dirty, I just think that’s the way football is being played now," Brady said.

The legend of Brock Osweiler begins

Hello, Tom Brady. Meet the new kid on the block, Brock Osweiler. He's 1-0 against you.

What are the Denver Broncos supposed to do with Brock Osweiler?

Open your wallet, Elway. It’s time to hand Brock Osweiler a big fat check.

With walking cast still on, Peyton Manning stays involved

Manning was able to study the game from that vantage, and offered Brock Osweiler advice after watching the first half.

Osweiler credits Peyton for halftime adjustments

Broncos quarterback Brock Osweiler told Sal Paolantonio of ESPN that the Broncos made halftime adjustments based on Manning’s observations of the first half. Manning was watching from inside and went into the locker room to tell Osweiler what he saw.

This is the C.J. Anderson we’ve all been waiting for

It’s time that Gary Kubiak starts leaning on Anderson once again. And that’s not to say that Hillman isn’t deserving of heavy run; he’s proven himself this season. But since getting that week of rest during the bye, Anderson has received less than 10 carries just twice … against the Colts and against the Chiefs, Denver’s only two losses.

Broncos are on pace for 54 sacks this season

The Denver Broncos' team record for sacks in a season is 57.

Broncos suddenly have a contracts problem for 2016

In the fourth year of his rookie contract, Osweiler is now only five regular-season games away from becoming eligible for unrestricted free agency. And if he hits the open market after with last night’s snow-globe takedown of the Patriots on his resume, one of the handful of teams with horrible quarterback situations (you know who you are) will gladly pay Osweiler big money to take the reins.

Mirror image: Broncos go with a young QB while for Colts, old is new

The Broncos' new starter, Brock Osweiler, is 2-0. He is 25 years old and was drafted in 2012. He took over for Manning, who is 39 years old and was drafted in 1998. The Colts' new starter, Matt Hasselbeck, is 4-0. He is 40 years old and was drafted in 1998, the same draft as Peyton Manning. He took over for Luck, who is 26 years old and was drafted in 2012, the same draft as Osweiler.

Brock Talk: No panic in leading comeback win

In his second start and facing an undefeated Patriots team, QB Brock Osweiler stayed poised and helped lead the Broncos to a comeback win over New England.

Broncos vs. Patriots wins primetime with overnight ratings on NBC's SNF

The Broncos' 30-24 overtime victory against the Patriots on NBC's Sunday Night Football posted a 16.2/26 overnight rating/share, meaning 16.2 percent of all households with televisions tuned in to the game and 26 percent of all households with televisions in use watched.

Osweiler called an audible into game-winning run in overtime

Brock Osweiler said after the Broncos beat the Patriots on Sunday night that he called an audible to check into C.J. Anderson’s 48-yard game-winning run in overtime.

What is wrong with Broncos WR Demaryius Thomas?

Is something wrong with Denver Broncos wide receiver Demaryius Thomas, who had possibly the worst game of his career against the New England Patriots?

Demaryius Thomas climbs Broncos’ all-time list onnight of struggles

The catch also gave Thomas 6,228 yards on his career and moved him ahead of Ed McCaffrey (6,200) for fourth place on the Broncos’ all-time receiving yards list.