clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

2017 NFL Draft: A tale of four quarterbacks

New, comments

How does Mr. Irrelevant stack up against other quarterbacks in the 2017 NFL Draft.

NCAA Football: Georgia Southern at Mississippi Justin Ford-USA TODAY Sports

The Denver Broncos used the final pick in the draft on QB, Chad Kelly, from Mississippi. Given that he was “Mr. Irrelevant” I assumed that his college numbers would have been poor. Why else would he have been the last guy picked in the draft? Trevor Siemian’s numbers in college were bad and he got hurt his senior year. That is why he was picked in the 7th round. I soon discovered that Chad Kelly was injured in his final year of college ball (missed the last 3 games) and that is one reason why he fell, but I was surprised to see how good his passing (and rushing stats) were particularly in comparison to three QBs drafted well before.

Below are the passing and rushing stats for four quarterbacks taken in the this draft: Mitch Trubisky - the #2 pick, DeShone Kizer - the 52nd pick, C.J. Beathard - the 104th pick and Chad Kelly - the 253rd pick. I have NOT listed the names by the stats, I have only shown them as QB1, QB2, QB3, and QB4.

First the passing stats for their college careers

Att Comp Pct. Yards Y/A TD Int
QB1 803 513 63.9% 6858 8.5 50 21
QB2 572 386 67.5% 4762 8.3 41 10
QB3 695 422 60.7% 5805 8.4 47 19
QB4 782 454 58.1% 5562 7.1 40 19

Note that all 4 are fairly close. QB2 had the best completion %, and the best TD/INT ratio. QB1 threw for more TDs, but in significantly more throws. QB3 and QB4 look very similar with the exception of Y/A and TDs. QB1 had the highest yards per passing attempt.

Now the rushing stats

Att Yards Avg. TD
QB1 204 949 4.7 16
QB2 120 439 3.7 8
QB3 264 997 3.8 18
QB4 224 429 1.9 10

QB1 looks like the most effective runner in terms of yards per carry and and touchdowns per carry. QB4 must have gotten sacked a bunch (sacks count against you rushing stats in college) to have 429 career rushing yards (and 10 TDs) while only gainin 1.9 ypc.

So have you guessed yet who is who from the stats? QB1 is Chad Kelly. QB2 is Mitch Trubisky. QB3 is Deshone Kizer and QB4 is C.J. Beathard. Did you guess correctly? Isn’t it amazing how much an injury and questions about maturity can hurt the draft stock of a QB given who similar the stats for these four QBs are?