clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Should Lyle Alzado be in the Broncos Ring of Fame?

Unlike like the man, the answer is an easy one to figure out.

Lyle Alzado

Good morning, Broncos Country!

A thought has been in my mind for the last week.

I know I’m not alone because a search on Mile High Report brings stories and FanPosts from the past on this topic. So it’s been on the minds of Denver Broncos fans for some time.

Why isn’t Lyle Alzado in the Ring of Fame? Should the former defensive lineman be in the Broncos Ring of Fame?

This question started to bounce around in my mind last weekend when I watched, for the third time, his “A Football Life.” If you haven’t seen it, it’s remarkable. It’s tragic. It’s compelling. It’s heartbreaking. It’s amazing.

For the sake of clarity, I wasn’t born when Alzado played in Denver. All I can do is base my opinion on what others have said about him, clips and his stats. Let’s start with stats. For official numbers, neither the NFL nor Pro Football Reference have them for his time in Denver. The defensive lineman played from 1971-1985, playing with the Broncos the longest, from ‘71-78. Alzado played in 196 games and started 195. In Denver, he played in 99 and started 98. That highlights his commitment. Alzado also was a two-time All Pro (once in Denver in 1977) and a two-time Pro Bowler (‘77-78). That speaks to his talent.

When you listen to former Broncos linebacker Tom Jackson and safety Billy Thompson, without Alzado there is no Orange Crush. He was the attitude and persona of that defense. Some even say Alzado was the face of the Orange Crush and the Broncos. The way fans flocked to him, you can see why. When you see the highlights, it makes total sense. He made everyone on the field better. That highlights his talents as a player and leader.

But as good as Alzado was on the field, and he was damn good, he was even better off of it. What he did in the community is legendary. He was acknowledged for that work with the Byron “Whizzer” White Award in 1977 (as a member of the Broncos). As the NFL Players Association story says, “The NFL Players Association annually recognizes players who go above and beyond to perform community service in their team cities and hometowns. The Byron ‘Whizzer’ White Award is the highest honor the NFLPA can bestow on a player.” That highlights the man but also the enigma that was Alzado.

So why isn’t Alzado in the Broncos Ring of Fame?

Andrew Mason shared his thoughts on the subject in a recent mailbag:

“Lyle Alazado did have some very good seasons with the Broncos, was very effective when he played with the Broncos. Why he isn’t in the Ring of Fame? Well, as good as he was, looking at some of the other players on the defense at the same time, he kind of comes in a notch below the Randy Gradishars, Louis Wrights, even a Paul Smith, who was there when Lyle Alzado first came to Denver and lingered through the Orange Crush years. Although (Smith) was kind of a rotational guy toward the end. Paul Smith was a bigger player in the early ‘70s, he’s in the Ring of Fame. Certainly the contentious nature of Alzado’s departure. There were some issues there.”

In my mind, it goes back to the enigma that Alzado was. He was a canon who could fire at the snap of a finger. Case in point: To this day there’s the “Lyle Alzado Rule” that says you can’t use your helmet as a weapon. But he also had the biggest heart. I think his steroid use plays a huge part in what people think about him. I would hope his time with the Raiders doesn’t play a role in that because that’s just silly. Perhaps Mason is right about how Alzado’s time in Denver ended is part of that, but the Ring of Fame committee needs to get over it. Shannon Sharpe played for and won a Super Bowl with the Baltimore Ravens. And there’s John Lynch. Both of them are in the Ring of Fame.

Alzado played a huge role in the Broncos’ first taste of success as a franchise. He was the face of one of the most historic defenses in NFL history. Heck, he may have been the face of the league come 1977. That means Alzado over the course of his eight seasons helped put the Broncos on the map. But all of that pales in comparison to what he did in the Denver community. All of that spells Ring of Famer.

Why isn’t Alzado in the Broncos Ring of Fame? I have no answer, but it’s time the committee get it fixed.


Should Lyle Alzado be in the Broncos Ring of Fame?

This poll is closed

  • 57%
    Heck yes!
    (395 votes)
  • 32%
    No shot, he played for the Raiders
    (227 votes)
  • 9%
    Perhaps, but not before ... (put in the comments)
    (68 votes)
690 votes total Vote Now

Broncos Tracks

Woody Paige: John Elway will become NFL's highest-paid VP/GM shortly | Colorado Springs Gazette, News
At four junctures in his football career, John Elway signed contracts making him the NFL's highest-paid player. As owner Pat Bowlen told me in the mid-1990s, "John has earned the right to be No. 1.'' Elway is about to become the league's highest-paid executive vice president-general manager.

This prophet wrote 10 commandments for all Broncos fans to follow |
"Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's season tickets"; It's commandment number eight on the tablets of the Mile High Prophet.

As camp approaches, Ed McCaffrey keeping a close eye on receiver competition
Ed McCaffrey is still watching his former team and carefully following the wide-receiver competition.

Fifteen players to watch at Broncos training camp -- 13. Jeff Heuerman
Finally blessed with good health, the 2015 draft pick knows that he must attack this summer with urgency in an offense that will give him opportunities.

Donor Alliance's Donor Dash holds special meaning for Eric Studesville
The Broncos' assistant head coach and running backs coach will participate for the second straight year.

Former Broncos QB coach 'Babe' Parilli dies |
Vito "Babe" Parilli, who helped guide quarterback Craig Morton to glory in the Denver Broncos' first Super Bowl-appearing season of 1977, died Saturday morning, the New England Patriots announced.

TBL: Josh Banderas ready to continue his push to make Denver Broncos roster | Big Red Today blog |
Former Husker linebacker Josh Banderas is ready to get back on the football field. Banderas signed with the Denver Broncos as an undrafted free agent.

AFC West Q&A: Who will win the division and how many teams make the playoffs?
The Raiders are the popular pick to win the AFC West, but they must find a way to end their woes versus the Chiefs, who also are expected to contend.

Q&A: Who is on the hottest seat in the AFC West?
The Chargers and Raiders aim to be ready to impress when new stadiums open, but right now it's Alex Smith hearing Patrick Mahomes' footsteps in K.C.

Q&A: Who is the rising star in the AFC West?
A solid rookie season has Hunter Henry poised to take over as the Chargers' primary tight end, but he's not the only rising star in the AFC West.

7 best teams in Broncos history | Broncos Wire
Which Denver Broncos team was the best? Here is a list of some of the top teams in franchise history.

John Elway could use Rams' interest as leverage with Broncos | NFL | Sporting News
John Elway has not yet received a new contract from the Broncos. It’s a deal that is expected to come by the end of the year, but that doesn’t mean the sharks aren’t circling.

John Elway Is Reportedly Poised To Become The NFL's Highest-Paid General Manager - Denver - Scout
John Elway is currently negotiating a contract extension with the Broncos that could make him the highest-paid GM in the NFL.

How the Denver Broncos can get John Elway locked in long-term
How can the Denver Broncos sort out the contract situation with John Elway? We dive in and take a look at an option that should at least be on the table.

NFL Tracks

Would NFL players actually go on strike in 2021? - Niners Nation
It’s going to take a lot, but it’s the only real opportunity for NFL players to change the system.

Richard Sherman says NFL players need to 'be willing to strike' for better salaries -
The Seahawks cornerback thinks NFL players should be willing to strike

Still challenged by eye trouble, Mike Zimmer vows, 'We’re not having more surgeries.'
MN Vikings coach Mike Zimmer is still waiting for the bubble keeping his right retina attached to dissolve. When it does, he might be able to see out of it with the help of a contact lens.

Tyrann Mathieu: I'm NFL's best defender if healthy -
Tyrann Mathieu suffered through a disappointing 2016 season after tearing his ACL late in 2015. Is he healthy enough to regain All-Pro form and lead the Cardinals back to the playoffs this year?

Darrelle Revis, Earl Thomas among top CFB DBs I've scouted -
Taylor. Polamalu. Reed. Bucky Brooks has seen some of the NFL's greatest defensive backs during his nearly two decades in scouting. See how he ranks the top 10 he's evaluated.

Who Dak Prescott Reminds Hall of Famer Charles Haley Of | NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth
Pro Football Hall of Fame defensive end Charles Haley has played with three Hall of Fame quarterbacks: Joe Montana, Steve Young and Troy Aikman. He tells NBC 5 sports director Newy Scruggs which one of those quarterbacks Dak Prescott reminds him of. 

NFL has 1st female replay official | |
IRVING, Texas — Terri Valenti always enjoyed football as a little girl, but never dreamed then of being in the NFL. That became her goal only after officiating games for

Marcus Mariota is on an unprecedented path to NFL greatness -
The Titans budding superstar could be the first quarterback from a college spread option offense to win a Super Bowl. Retired NFL lineman Geoff Schwartz explains.

Here are five teams that will fall short of returning to the NFL playoffs in 2017 -
Parity will rear its head, and some teams won't be back in the playoffs for consecutive seasons

Relaxed celebration rules clear about what’s legal, NFL head of officiating says | ProFootballTalk
Ezekiel Elliott still will get penalized for leaping into the Salvation Army kettle, but the Packers can feel free to have the entire offense do the Lambeau Leap. The celebration rules are clear, the league's head of officiating said Friday, regarding what actions will result in a 15-yard penalty.

Yes, The NFL Is Still Making Assloads Of Money
Even if it sometimes feels like we’ve already hit peak NFL, the league’s biggest source of revenue is guaranteed and ever-increasing.

NFL business - What will and what won't happen over next three seasons 2020 future power rankings
A change in Roger Goodell's power over the NFL? Not happening. Guaranteed contracts for players? Likely not. Sponsorship logos on NFL jerseys? Count on it. Kevin Seifert predicts issues that will be solved and problems that will remain in three years.

Dallas Cowboys running back Ezekiel Elliott preparing response to NFL investigation
Dallas Cowboys running back Ezekiel Elliott has received a report from the NFL on its findings from an investigation into a 2016 domestic violence accusation against him, and Elliott is preparing a response to the league.

Christian McCaffrey: Panthers not worried about Cam -
There's a lot of unknown surrounding the offense in Charlotte as training camp approaches, but Christian McCaffrey is confident the team, and his rehabbing quarterback, will thrive.

What NFL players need to do to get paid like their NBA counterparts
The NFLPA needs to focus on eliminating the franchise tag and the rookie contract system — two barriers that limit player earnings and wreck their contract leverage.

Manziel 'hopeful' for NFL comeback but 'I know the situation that I put myself in' -
Johnny Manziel's been out of the NFL for over a year and now realizes how much he misses the game

Three Reasons to Start Getting Excited for the NFL Season
We’re in a sports dead period. But salvation awaits. A coaching quagmire in Dallas and a pair of quarterback conundrums have got us fired up about football season.

Gene Frenette: Jaguars’ Taylor, like many great NFL players, may wait forever on HOF | Jacksonville News, Sports and Entertainment |
This much needs to be said about Fred Taylor’s football career: He left the game as one of the most underrated running backs in NFL history, though not by his primary employer, who inducted him into the Pride of the Jaguars.

Gordon: Bolts want to win Super Bowl for Gates, Rivers -
The newly minted Los Angeles Chargers are now less than a month away from their first game in their new digs and running back Melvin Gordon is ready to make a important first impression.