clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

What should the Denver Broncos do with Trevor Siemian and Paxton Lynch?

Get rid of them both? Keep both? Part ways with one, but which one? Let’s break down the pros and cons.

NFL: Green Bay Packers at Denver Broncos Ron Chenoy-USA TODAY Sports

The real question the Denver Broncos must answer is what to do with Trevor Siemian and Paxton Lynch heading into the offseason.

I think only one remains on the roster, but which one largely depends on how John Elway solves the starting quarterback position in free agency and/or the 2018 NFL Draft.

Once that riddle is solved, here are the pros and cons of keeping either quarterback on the roster.

Trevor Siemian

Why he should be kept: He has the respect of his teammates and ample game experience. He would likely make a fine backup, but the biggest question is how long his psyche would hold up if thrust into the starting lineup again.

Another positive is his current contract situation. He will cost just $705,000 in 2018 to keep on the roster, but with a mere $13,196 in dead money he could easily become a training camp cut casualty without much impact on the teams financial balance sheets.

Why he should be cut/traded: He’s not a good quarterback and may not even be a good backup quarterback at this point. Of the two, I don’t even think Siemian has much trade value at this point having finished as the second-worst starting quarterback in the NFL last season. If Elway has no desire to move on from Lynch, then Siemian will likely be cut sooner rather than later.

Paxton Lynch

Why he should be kept: He is entering year three and he was universally called a 2-3 year project coming out of college. If the team is serious about its own draft evaluations and expectations, then Lynch should absolutely be given the chance to progress. Unfortunately, in limited playing time and ample practice time, he hasn’t exactly shown much of that progress.

Ironically, his contract situation is also a reason he should be kept. Rather than take the $2M in dead money, the Broncos are likely to invest more time into their former first-round pick.

Why he should be cut/traded: He’s not a good quarterback and may never be starter worthy. If that’s the case, then the best option is to go find a sucker of a GM out there who will think he can salvage the first round pick. As foolish as that sounds, there will be one out there who would trade a 5th round pick for Ty Sambrail... err, Paxton Lynch.

Who should the Broncos keep?

I’m leaning towards dealing both and starting fresh in 2018, but the Broncos are unlikely to go with that much wholesale change in one year. My guess is they keep Lynch and get rid of Siemian, but if I were Elway I’d probably cut bait with Lynch first. From many, many reports over the last two years, Siemian at least works hard and is a coaches dream, so why not keep him in that film room moving forward?

What do you think Broncos Country?

Horse Tracks

Broncos sign three players to future contracts
Kenny Bell, Andreas Knappe and DeShawn Williams signed deals Wednesday.

East-West Shrine Game practice: Day 3
BTV's Andrew Mason and Steve Atwater recap Day 3 of the East-West Shrine Game practices.

How Baker Mayfield wound up with Boulder-based agents Jack and Tom Mills
In an industry where quarterback representation is dominated by the likes Creative Artists Agency (CAA) and Athletes First, Mayfield's decision to align with the Mills' was the biggest surprise since Tom Cruise warded off Jay Mohr for the rights to Cuba Gooding Jr.

Should Broncos go after Teddy Bridgewater in 2018?
Teddy Bridgewater wil be an unrestricted free agent this offseason. Does he fit with the Denver Broncos?

Eagles’ Super Bowl dreams are still alive because of Fletcher Cox
Cox turned routine plays into great ones, shutting down a potent Falcons’ offense. He gets the nod for retired NFL defensive end Stephen White’s Hoss of the Week award.

Will Jaguars trash talk fail vs. Patriots?
The Patriots thrive on bulletin board material, but they’re also going up against arch nemesis Tom Coughlin. Plus, which scary defense will come out on top between the Vikings and Eagles?

Case Keenum, Nick Foles are better without Jeff Fisher
Keenum and Foles are playing for an NFC Championship because Jeff Fisher isn’t their coach anymore.

Vikings’ video shows the incredible range of emotions fans went through during the ‘Minneapolis Miracle’
This is why sports are the best.

Tom Brady injury update: Patriots QB hurts right hand before AFC title
You shouldn’t worry about ol’ Tom.

Jacksonville bakery sends Ben Roethlisberger 7 turnovers as a thank you
Pettiness is a dish best served warm, with a delicious fruit filling.