clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

2019 NFL Draft: guys I love, guys I don’t

New, comments

Time for John Elway and the Denver Broncos to wake up and grab these guys in the 2019 NFL Draft.

NCAA Football: Brigham Young at Boise State
He may not have the most talent in this class, but Rypien should find a home in the league.
Brian Losness-USA TODAY Sports

One of the best parts of draft season is getting familiar with a lot of future studs in the league. It’s sort of similar to growing up and finding a band that you’re into before they’re all over the radio.

So this list won’t have the guys I’ve done full GIF Horse pieces on. My plan here is to shine a little light on some other guys that really won me over the last couple of months. Then there are a couple I just don’t get the hype on. If Elway drafts one, I’ll hope for the best, but I didn’t see it when I watched their tape.

One Linebacker I love: Blake Cashman

It’s been trendy to fall for Cashman since he blew up the Combine, but when you turn on the tape it’s hard to ignore how good he looks. I had this to say two weeks ago:

Studying prospects at this time of year you hear that every guy is a hard worker, but there aren’t many who choose to walk on at their hometown school and grind their way to where Cashman’s gotten. He’d be an exceptional locker room guy from day 1 and fits the Fangio scheme to a T. He makes reads quickly, can anticipate where the ball is going and works to get through trash. He has short arms and is just 237 lbs, but is willing at the point of attack and capable of chasing down ball carriers on wide runs. He’ll be a massive upgrade over Josey Jewell in coverage, comes fundamentally sound, and if he can stay healthy, the sky’s the limit.

One thing this draft is short on is linebackers who play as well as they test, but that won’t be a concern with the Golden Gopher.

The Z Receiver I love: N’Keal Harry

So long as he falls to the right staff, I think Harry will be the best receiver from this class. I wrote about him at length here, but let me elaborate. If the Broncos trade down from 10 to, say, 20? Harry’s probably the guy I’m hoping for. If Elway wants him, that may well be where they have to get him. I don’t think he’ll be there at 41 with teams like Green Bay, Baltimore, and Arizona ahead of them.

The Tight End I love: Kahale Warring

If you’re looking for the closest thing to T.J. Hockenson after the first round, Warring’s your prospect. He’s unrefined and will need coaching to reach his potential, but the tools are there for the San Diego State product to come in and solve the Broncos tight end conundrum for the next decade. There’s a reason he’s been my tight end the last two Mock drafts I’ve done.

Another Linebacker I love: Ben Burr-Kirven

I wrote about BBK at length a few weeks ago.

He’s the kind of guy that wins despite the negatives. One of the biggest strengths of his game is playing in space as he’s a natural coverage player and brings the kind of twitchy athleticism that Todd Davis and Josey Jewell don’t. While he’s definitely undersized he’s slippery, so blockers need to work to keep their hands on his jersey. He’s incredibly instinctive and active, both things that coaches love and could hone to turn him into a heat seeking missile at the professional level.

The Washington Husky is a guy you can’t root against. He has a clear weakness in his game, but also shows enough flashes that I think he can overcome it in the right system. When you stop and consider that the Broncos will use nickel personnel more than 50% of the time next year, he makes even more sense. He’d be the space player Denver currently lacks with Josey Jewell on the field.

...and a linebacker I don’t: Khalil Hodge

Hard pass.

The Quarterback I love: Brett Rypien

There are a number of factors that matter a great deal to me when evaluating quarterbacks. The biggest one is accuracy. By and large, it can’t be taught. The second one is mental capacity. It’s hard to quantify or even properly gauge on broadcast tape, but there are things you look for, such as using their eyes to manipulate defenders, the ability to stand tall with a pass rush bearing down, and reading through his progressions to find the open receiver.

Rypien displays all of these things in spades. He started 50 games at Boise State and completed 64% of his passes for 13,578 yards, 90 touchdowns and 29 interceptions. On film you routinely see him make multiple reads and hang in the saddle without dropping his eyes. He doesn’t have the biggest arm, he isn’t super mobile, and he’s a bit undersized, but he has as good a chance to hang around the league for a decade as anyone in this class.

The Quarterback I don’t: Jarrett Stidham

In a lot of ways, the Auburn Tiger is like that bad relationship you can’t walk away from. The facts are indisputable, but you keep telling yourself “it’s not their fault.”

That’s Stidham. You read his bio, and from afar things look promising. He was a top 50 recruit coming out of high school. He won the 2017 Iron Bowl over Alabama. Scouts say he didn’t have much help last year.

Then you turn on the tape and the evidence is staring you in the fact. Stidham crumbles like a wafer under pressure. It isn’t just one thing, either. He doesn’t always see it coming, he drops his eyes, he’ll panic throw into traffic.

The first time I watched his 2018, I tried to buy into the narrative. Auburn’s system didn’t always do him favors and the supporting cast did fail him here and there. So I turned on the 2017 tape to see this incredible Iron Bowl that put him on the radar. Even there, you see the signs.

Some think Stidham can flourish with professional coaching. I heard on Matt Miller’s Stick to Football Podcast yesterday that he sees him as a possible heir to Tom Brady. The belief seems to be that he just needs to be brought in, sheltered, given a binky, a blanky, and perhaps a nightlight. Count me out. I might sign him as a camp arm, nothing more.

The guard I love: Dru Samia

You’ll start to notice a lot of these guys have shown up in my Monday Mock draft series. For good reason, I don’t like to take guys unless I believe in them. I believe in Samia. He isn’t a fit in every scheme which is why he’ll slide on draft day, but if Rich Scangarello is running an outside zone based offense? He’s a hand in glove fit, and a junkyard dog to boot.

The Corner I don’t: Greedy Williams

Andraez Williams looks like a very talented player, so don’t confuse this lack of affection as anything more than concerns. The LSU Tiger profiles as an exceptional press man cover corner at the next level and the kind of scheme transcendent talent a team would be lucky to have. If Denver picked him up late in the 1st or if he somehow slipped to 41? I’d be pretty excited, but I don’t think his skillset will be maximized at 10th overall and his reluctance to tackle would be an issue on a Fangio D.

I’m still working on my final adjusted big board, so look for it in an upcoming GIF Horse. Until then, let me know what you think in the comments Broncos Country.

Your Broncos Links

Denver Broncos: Can Andy Janovich be more than a fullback? - Mile High Report

Andy Janovich addressed Broncos Country for the first time during Denver Broncos voluntary work outs this week.

Drew Lock is having his official pre-draft visit with the Broncos - Mile High Report

It started last night and will continue through today. The Denver Broncos are having a pre-draft meeting with Missouri quarterback Drew Lock.

Two Denver Broncos legends to announce picks at 2019 NFL Draft - Mile High Report

Al Wilson and Karl Mecklenburg will announce the Denver Broncos picks in the second and third rounds of the 2019 NFL Draft.

2019 NFL Draft Scouting Report: Iowa tight end Noah Fant - Mile High Report

Iowa tight end Noah Fant is a prospect who could help transform the Denver Broncos’ offense.

Discussion: Who don’t you want the Denver Broncos to draft? - Mile High Report

I asked the MHR gang who they’d hate to don the orange and blue.

What would it take for the Denver Broncos draft considered a success? - Mile High Report

I asked the MHR what they’re looking for this year to make the Denver Broncos draft class a success.

Denver Broncos discussion: Lock, Murray, Haskins, or Jones? - Mile High Report

I asked the MHR Gang who they like at quarterback. Which first round talent should the Denver Broncos go after - if at all.

Here’s how the Denver Broncos draft could turn into an absolute failure - Mile High Report

I asked the MHR gang what they’d hate to see the Denver Broncos do in the 2019 NFL Draft.

The Players That Made Me: Steve Atwater’s favorite players from a life in football

Through this collection of players — from “Mean” Joe Greene to Ronnie Lott, to Emmanuel Sanders and Todd Davis — track Steve Atwater’s path from growing up in St. Louis to establishing a Ring of Fame career and beyond.

NFL draft: Should teams wait for Tua Tagovailoa, Justin Herbert? | SI.com

The 2019 draft is still more than two weeks away, but some quarterback-needy teams might already be thinking about next year (and maybe even the year after)—so here’s a quick look at some of the QBs who will likely be in the ’20 draft class.

Ranking NFL teams RB situations, best to worst | SI.com

6. Denver Broncos, $3.6 / $167.6 million Phillip Lindsay, Royce Freeman, Devontae Booker, Khalfani Muhammad If you find a Pro Bowler as an undrafted free agent, and supplement him with a bigger-bodied third-round pick capable of giving a breather and grinding time, you’re going to have flexibility in other spots.

Denver Broncos Mock Draft Monday - The Haul - Mile High Report

One trade led to another and the Denver Broncos wound up with 6 top 100 picks in my latest Mock Draft.

NFL Mock Draft: Raiders trade for #1 pick, Kyler Murray | SI.com

10. Denver: Drew Lock, QB, Missouri John Elway takes another shot at drafting Denver’s quarterback of the future in Lock, who will benefit from a year on the bench behind the newly acquired Joe Flacco. After Murray and Haskins, there’s a drop-off in QB talent in this draft, but that won’t stop a QB-desperate team from spending an early pick on a developmental player with great physical tools like Lock.

FMIA’s Non-Mock NFL Draft: What Each Team Should Do in First Round – ProFootballTalk

10. Denver: Devin White, LB, LSU. Vic Fangio froths at putting the best linebacker and a sure, physical tackler between Von Miller and Bradley Chubb. Keep hearing Denver and a quarterback here, but it’s not what I’d do this year, this high.

Your NFL Links

Would Seahawks trade Russell Wilson and draft a new QB? | SI.com

I seriously doubt it, but I’d reach out to them to make sure.

N’Keal Harry’s world tour ramps up – ProFootballTalk

Arizona State wide receiver N’Keal Harry has gained a lot of notice this offseason. That also means he’s gaining lots hours in the air and meals on someone else’s tab.

Antonio Brown: JuJu Smith-Schuster fumbled our postseason away – ProFootballTalk

Antonio Brown is done in Pittsburgh, but he’s not done taking shots at his former teammates. Brown tweeted this afternoon that Steelers wide receiver JuJu Smith-Schuster cost the Steelers a playoff berth when he fumbled late in their Week 16 loss to the Saints.

JuJu Smith-Schuster: Crazy how big Antonio Brown’s ego got – ProFootballTalk

It didn’t take long for JuJu Smith-Schuster to respond to Antonio Brown ripping Smith-Schuster on social media. After Brown said Smith-Schuster fumbled the Steelers’ postseason away, Smith-Schuster expressed surprise that a former friend would take a shot at him like that.

Josh Rosen shows up for offseason workouts, but what will he say? – ProFootballTalk

As expected, Cardinals quarterback Josh Rosen showed up for the launch of the team’s offseason workout program. The bigger question is what, if anything, he’ll have to say?