clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

NFL owners proposed an 18 game schedule with a limit of 16 games per player

New, comments

I’m not personally a big fan of this proposed schedule change.

Los Angeles Chargers v Denver Broncos Photo by Dustin Bradford/Getty Images

It was reported on Friday that the NFL owners proposed to the NFLPA an 18-game schedule, but with a catch. The catch is that there is a 16 game limit for every player. Obviously meaning that you would at least need to bench every player on your 53-man roster for at least two games.

That’s a bit wild.

The obvious motivation for such a move is revenue. Every NFL game is a bit of a gold mine and two more games would only make the owners even more money. However, it appears that the players are going to be against any rule that makes them sit out two regular season games.

Here are the hurdles I see in this rather out of the box proposal.

Roster expansion?

If every player would have to sit out at least two games, you would need to expand the roster size a good deal.

Look, each team lists seven players per game as inactive so you would have to get very creative to make it work with a 53-man roster. You would have to up it to at least a 63-man roster to even make it work. Hell, you would likely have to add more considering you would need to use three of those spots on an extra kicker, punter, and long snapper.

It just doesn’t make much sense on paper.

Sitting your star quarterbacks

This proposed rule would obviously mean that your star quarterbacks would have to sit out two games. So your Patrick Mahomes, Tom Brady, Russell Wilson, Phillip Rivers and so on would all have sit out two games and have their backups start those games.

Barring an injury, you would have to pick two games on your schedule where you think you can win without your backup quarterback(and likely other starters). Removing your star players who are already overprotected now is a bit of an odd strategy for the NFL.

Who is going to pay to watch a backup quarterback and others play in a meaningful NFL game? This works in the Broncos favor because of Drew Lock, but obviously not every team is as fortunate. Hell, you would have Blake Bortles leading the high-powered Rams offense.

Watering down your product

Preseason play is a great example of how watered down the sport can get once you remove the roster worthy players.

Second teams offensive line play is often atrocious league-wide. Is there 32 backup worthy quarterbacks in the league and can you find 32 more long snappers, kickers, and punters? If you can, they’re likely not very good and you will be paying full price to watch them play.

Relying on these players to win you games when every NFL game means so much just seems like a shit deal.

Final thoughts

I think a 16-game schedule is fine the way it is. I get the NFL and their owners want even more money(despite them already swimming in pools of money) but an 18 game schedule with these parameters seems like something that would blow up in the NFL’s face.

What do you think MHR? Are you in favor of an 18-game schedule with a 16 game limit for all players? Or do you just want them to just keep it the way it is?

Poll

Are you in favor of an 18 game schedule with a 16 game limit?

This poll is closed

  • 17%
    Yes! Change is always good
    (123 votes)
  • 82%
    NO! If it ain’t broken, don’t fix it
    (589 votes)
712 votes total Vote Now

NFL news

Tony Corrente: Expanding replay to include PI opens “new box” – ProFootballTalk
Retired NFL referee John Parry recently said expanded replay to include pass interference opens "Pandora's Box." Current NFL referee Tony Corrente agrees.

Jaire Alexander predicts All-Pro honors this season – ProFootballTalk
Jaire Alexander didn't make the Pro Bowl as a rookie. The Packers cornerback did make 11 starts, 61 tackles and an interception, getting his career off to a solid start. The 18th overall choice in 2018 has bigger goals this season. “Year two? I’m going to be All-Pro.

Cowboys still own Rolando McClain’s rights – ProFootballTalk
Rolando McClain has retired three times and currently is serving his third NFL suspension. The former linebacker hasn't played since 2015. But McClain says he wants to come back . . . again. First, the NFL would have to reinstate McClain, who received an indefinite suspension on Dec. 2, 2016.

Offensive linemen hold their own summit to try to counter pass rushers – ProFootballTalk
Broncos linebacker Von Miller started a pass-rushing summit three years ago. It prompted the league's offensive linemen to start their own get together two years ago.

Report: Derrius Guice injures hamstring – ProFootballTalk
A couple months ago, Washington running back Derrius Guice was expecting to be full-go at the start of training camp. That may no longer be the case. Guice has suffered a hamstring injury and may miss the start of training camp, Erin Hawksworth of 106.7 The Fan reports.

Rams’ strength and conditioning coach found not guilty – ProFootballTalk
Jurors in California found Rams strength and conditioning coach Ted Rath not guilty of three counts of sexual battery, the Ventura County Star reports. A Ventura County Superior Court jury deliberated about an hour Friday before returning with the verdict, according to the newspaper.

Source: NFL has one-way option to exit DirecTV deal at end of 2019 season – ProFootballTalk
Conflicting reports have emerged in recent weeks regarding the duration of the NFL's deal with DirecTV and, more importantly, the league's ability to pull the plug on it prematurely. Sports Business Journal previously reported that the league must exercise it's ability to opt out of the $1.

Mark Murphy supports 17 games a regular-season compromise – ProFootballTalk
Given the conflicting quotes attributed to Packers CEO Mark Murphy on Friday, I opted to pretend to be an actual reporter and do some actual reporting. Short story shorter, I got Murphy on the phone to clarify his thoughts on a potentially expanded regular season.

Making the Leap: 24 reasons why Browns' Nick Chubb will shine - NFL.com
Nick Chubb impressed as a rookie, but Gregg Rosenthal expects an even better showing from the RB in Year 2. Have a look at 24 reasons why we should expect more from the Cleveland Browns' budding star in 2019.

Ranking defensive triplets; a growing trend in NFL team-building - NFL.com
Which teams boast the best DEFENSIVE triplets in the NFL today? How do running backs factor into the latest team-building trend? Bucky Brooks explores those topics -- and more -- in this week's notebook.

2019 NFL season: Finding homes for top remaining free agents - NFL.com
Could Jay Ajayi make a difference for the Colts? Should Eric Berry reunite with John Dorsey in Cleveland? Gil Brandt finds the best team fits for the top remaining free agents.

Matt Nagy excited for Bears to be in prime position - NFL.com
Second-year coach Matt Nagy is plenty excited that his Bears will be playing in prime time on five occasions. "You want to have as many prime time games as possible," he said on Total Access.

Rolando McClain seeks return after three-year absence - NFL.com
After being suspended indefinitely in 2016 for repeatedly failed drug tests, Rolando McClain, the No. 8 overall pick in the 2010 NFL Draft, announced Friday that he is applying for reinstatement.

NFL Superstar Club: Deshaun Watson gets in, Tom Brady booted - NFL.com
Every summer, Dan Hanzus serves as the bouncer of The Superstar Club, a home for the NFL's most special players. Who's in and who's out this time around? Well, a few decisions are sure to surprise ...

Eric Weddle calls Rams CBs 'best I've ever played with' - NFL.com
Heading into his first season with the Rams, safety Eric Weddle says Aaron Donald is the best player in the NFL and cornerbacks Aqib Talib and Marcus Peters are the best CBs he's played with.

Cowboys' Dak Prescott against taking hometown deal - NFL.com
Dak Prescott has been one of the league's biggest bargains for three years now. Set to become a free agent after this season, the Cowboys quarterback intimated he's ready to cash in.

Raiders guard Richie Incognito suspended two games - NFL.com
The NFL has suspended Oakland Raiders guard Richie Incognito two games for violating the personal conduct policy, NFL Network's Tom Pelissero reported.