clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

The Quarterback Decision No Bull Review

The Denver Broncos are searching for a QB for the 6th year straight...get the No Bull take on what this decision means to the team and the fans

Denver Broncos v Seattle Seahawks Photo by Steph Chambers/Getty Images

We’ve got two preseason games and most of the Broncos 2021 training camp under our belts and still, there is nary a starting quarterback named for the Denver Broncos.

I’ve shied away from speaking directly about the competition in my reviews trusting to the process of training camp and the preseason games to show me the reality of what direction the Broncos will go for their 2021 NFL season. But enough with giving the wily vet and the young buck time...a decision has to be made and here’s what it boils down to from this analyst’s point of view.

The Broncos Standard

We’ve been sold the line about the “Broncos Standard” that Pat Bowlen set as being the guiding force for everything the team does for decades. I’m not going to debate the wisdom of that or rightness of it, but I can tell you what that standard means. When Pat was of sound mind, it meant one word:

Winning.

If this team is ever going to get back to the form it was back in the 90s and 00s, they have to get back to this goal as directing their path. The Broncos need to win games.

Vic Fangio needs to win games or he is going to lose his job.

George Paton needs the Broncos to win games or he is going to be ran through the ringer for years for passing on Justin Fields.

The “ownership” of the team needs them to win games so they can get the best deal possible on whomever the future owner will be of the team.

And last, but certainly not least, The Broncos fans need them to win games.

  • 2017: 5 - 11
  • 2018: 6 - 10
  • 2019: 7 - 9
  • 2020: 5 - 11

The Broncos haven’t sucked this bad since 1969 - 1972 by comparison (5-8, 5-8, 4-9, 5-9)

Teddy Bridgewater is named the starter because...

Denver Broncos v Seattle Seahawks Photo by Steph Chambers/Getty Images

He gives the team the best chance to win games consistently week in and week out. He’s far more accurate, understands how to move in the pocket, and has leadership in spades.

He’s shown more consistent play through training camp and in preseason action.

...and most importantly, while he doesn’t pose as big a threat with his arm as Lock does, he puts the team in a position to win instead of putting them in a position to lose.

This team is coached by Vic Fangio who is one of the greatest defensive minds in the NFL right now. Fangio’s team is going to win by having a great defense and not making mistakes on offense. That seals the deal in my mind of which quarterback gives the Broncos the best chance to have a successful season.

If Drew Lock is named the starter...

Denver Broncos v Seattle Seahawks Photo by Steph Chambers/Getty Images

It means that George Paton has more weight with the decision than he should. That’s the play that gives you a better draft pick with a very small chance of your young buck turning into a legit starting NFL QB.

While both QBs took turns running the 1s and the 2s in the preseason game, Drew fell to pieces without starting talent around him. His pocket presence lacked greatly, and he led the team to field goals instead of touchdowns.

The two games we saw him in were a microcosm of what we saw in the past 1.5 years from Drew Lock. If things go right and the defense is easy to read, he’s a wizard. If he gets pressured and doesn’t have players playing great around him, he looks like a backup quarterback at best.

Drew Lock simply hasn’t earned the privilege of starting from what I’ve seen from his play on the field. Kudos to him for not throwing picks like he’s giving out candy at a parade. That’s one step in the right direction...but for him to get the nod he needed to take two or three more steps.

Final Thoughts

For me, I see a lot of what I saw around the team in the 2015 NFL season: subpar quarterback play means the offense is not going to be a beast, a front seven that is going to cause havoc for opposing passers, and a secondary that is going to be so good that opposing teams have trouble finding the open man downfield.

If this team is going to do anything well this year, it is going to come down to the defense. We don’t need a hero at QB for that game plan. We need a QB who will manage the offense, consistently put points on the board, and help us audible out of bad situations to keep from making big mistakes.

Broncos Country has always been pretty crazy when it comes to talking quarterbacks, and this year is no exception. I keep hearing from people about how Lock just needs time and he’s practically a rookie. Nonsense. This is his 3rd year in the league. Everyone else had to deal with Covid last year, too. No head coach with any sense is going to make the call to start Lock if their goal is winning football games... not with what we’ve seen from both Lock and Bridgewater through training camp and in preseason action.

Poll

Pick your Week 1 starter.

This poll is closed

  • 47%
    Drew Lock
    (4196 votes)
  • 52%
    Teddy Bridgewater
    (4661 votes)
8857 votes total Vote Now